That display is not going unnoticed by prospective jurors. Expect it to continue as witnesses in trial do not testify to his sterling qualities, either.This is the best part of jury selection for me. pic.twitter.com/7YeqzxhUix
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 18, 2024
Adventus
"I would like to say 'This book is written to the glory of God', but nowadays this would be the trick of a cheat, i.e., it would not be correctly understood."--Ludwig Wittgenstein
"OH JESUS OH WHAT THE FUCK OH WHAT IS THIS H.P. LOVECRAFT SHIT OH THERE IS NO GOD I DID NOT SIGN UP FOR THIS—Popehat
Thursday, April 18, 2024
Schadenfreude
Those Who Weren’t There Are Always The Most Expert
The "counterculture” was never popular so much as infamous. Most of the radical personalities were either rich kids or made money off their fame (no Springsteen working class characters, IOW), and college graduates who emulated Dustin Hoffman’s “Graduate” quickly turned into Yuppies after Nixon gave us Carter, and Reagan told us greed and racism were “good” again. Which is what really buried the Democrats. I was in college starting three years after Kent State. The biggest national craze associated with college students was streaking.Putting aside the '68 protest was days after MLK's murder, some of these antics of the counterculture movement helped bury Democrats at the national level for more than two decades. Nixon won in 1968 and until Clinton shocked people in 1992 there was a nearly unbroken streak of… https://t.co/wAsDXhdaSg
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 18, 2024
These Are Not The Defenses You Are Looking For 👀
The “political attacks” defense doesn’t fly in the context of a criminal case. Try harder.Trump has until Friday night at 5 pm to submit his response. But one of his lawyers previewed his defense: Trump is merely defending himself from political attacks, the order is ambiguous, and his “republication” of others’ statements cannot constitute a violation. 8/
— Lisa Rubin (@lawofruby) April 18, 2024
LOCK HIM UP!
Lot of loose talk (“The horror! The horror!”) about Trump “getting away with something” because he’s not in jail for life yet.NBC News: Trump is using his phone in the courtroom, openly flouting the rules of the courtroom. Blanche just told him to stop and Trump tucked the phone in his pocket while looking annoyed. @MSNBC
— Kyle Griffin (@kylegriffin1) April 18, 2024
ELECTION INTERFERENCE!!!
It’s a representative government (something I remind myself in Texas every day):AZ State Rep who works for Charlie Kirk’s TPUSA drops out of his race for Congress today after allegations surfaced that he forged signatures on petitions to get on the ballot. Story …https://t.co/iakGUulMma
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 18, 2024
A reminder:It’s amazing how irresponsible you are able to be when you represent R+36 (Gaetz) and R+32 (Greene) districts. You can be wholly out of touch with most of America and nothing you do matters. https://t.co/n1NBiHft6b
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 18, 2024
Trump has only 10 peremptory challenges, and he’s used some (I don’t know how many). He can move the judge to dismiss “for cause,” so long as the judge agrees. At some point, probably soon, the jury will be seated. Trump can’t do very much about that.They include a lawyer, a hedge funder, an investment banker, a woman in publishing, a teacher turned stay-at-home mom, and a retired college administrator. And according to @nytimes, these are not the jurors Trump’s looking for.https://t.co/hUvOC7PmRt
— Lisa Rubin (@lawofruby) April 18, 2024
I’ve been told this is not the same thing as pre-Pearl Harbor isolationism, but I don’t think that leopard has really changed its spots.Marge Gone Wild: “I don’t care if the Speaker’s office becomes a revolving door … The days are over of the old Republican Party that wants to fund foreign wars and murder people while they stab the American people in their face!” pic.twitter.com/yUrQ814Nwp
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 18, 2024
I’m guessing she also voted against the infrastructure bill:MCCONNELL: "Here's the political reality: if you think the fall of Afghanistan was bad, the fall of a European capital like Kyiv to Russian troops will be unimaginably worse, and if stalled American assistance makes that outcome possible, there's no question...where the blame…
— Frank Thorp V (@frankthorp) April 18, 2024
So far, the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law has delivered $8.7 billion to WA with 670+ specific projects identified for funding statewide.
— Rep. Rick Larsen (@RepRickLarsen) April 18, 2024
Every day is infrastructure day. https://t.co/W1fnItyhzl
I’m sure we could find the same corruption of officeholders in America. But I’m guessing it will be h, since they don’t tend to announce the bribes at press conferences or in the steps of the Capitol.Today, Belgium announced two things.
— Jay in Kyiv (@JayinKyiv) April 18, 2024
- Discovered a network of Putin's goons bribing EU politicians
- Rushing F-16's to Ukraine in the next 40 days instead of in 2025.
Probably unrelated. pic.twitter.com/wDRtUDtDqd
At this political moment: Here’s what happens when Rep Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) speaks at Capitol pic.twitter.com/ifdoGdL6bK
— Scott MacFarlane (@MacFarlaneNews) April 18, 2024
🔔 🔔🔔
Lara Trump downplays hush money charges as simple 'bookkeeping error'https://t.co/5RRhwr8xHe
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 18, 2024
The ex-president's campaign circulated talking points ahead of the trial, which started Monday, directing surrogates to describe the case as a "a full-frontal assault on American Democracy and the Constitution" and a "witch hunt," and recommending that supporters do not refer to the case as a "hush money case," but to instead describe it as "entries in the company’s records."Oops.
That’s known by a technical legal term called: “confession.” Part of the crime here is that Trump hid the payments to Stormy Daniels by repaying Michael Cohen for paying her, and booking the payments as “legal fees.” And yet here he is, confessing he made the payments to her personally, so that he can’t be guilty of campaign finance law violations. 34 of them, according to the indictment. But for business fraud, not violating campaign finance laws.I assume this will be played in dopey’s trial. I’m sure his defense wont be to try and deny his reimbursements to Cohen were for his payment to Stormy, since he confessed to that over a year ago. https://t.co/PyHATkkPzd
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 18, 2024
Abort! Abort!!
Arizona House Republicans Again Refuse to Take Up Repeal of 1864 Abortion Ban, Burst Into Applause After Vote https://t.co/fqb8RdmU4C
— MeidasTouch (@MeidasTouch) April 17, 2024
Abbott and Paxton are acting this way (they don’t even care about abortion). I’m still wondering if they’re rocketing toward a rude awakening.It's like they're cutting ads for Arizona Democrats https://t.co/ab9FwqaKNz pic.twitter.com/X8fl7eoQpj
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) April 18, 2024
We live in hope. Well, some of us do.Pelosi: I think they should take a lesson in the birds and the bees. I don't think these guys even know what's going on when it comes to all of that. But I do know that not understanding that a woman's right to choose is a democracy issue. It's a freedom issue. pic.twitter.com/ND8VuQDIzE
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 18, 2024
Wednesday, April 17, 2024
Do They Still Make Bumper Stickers?
A) How many people know who Mayorkas is? Or particularly care?Would be curious how many swing voters know Mayorkas's name https://t.co/jOEGxb45Qn
— Ben Jacobs (@Bencjacobs) April 17, 2024
I think you’ll be better off selling this one:In an effort to dismiss Trump's coup attempt impeachment as “unconstitutional” because Trump was no longer in office, 45 Republicans — including leader Mitch McConnell — voted in favor of dismissal while only five voted with all 50 Democrats to proceed with the trial. https://t.co/fpiMQf1OQi
— S.V. Dáte (@svdate) April 18, 2024
Don’t see it fitting on a bumper sticker, though.The theory being presented here by Rep. Murphy is Trump’s Secretary of the Army delayed the national guard response to January 6th because he wanted more chaos because he wanted a job in the Biden Administration? https://t.co/LzpTPDVIjO
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 18, 2024
Idle Hands and Somebody’s Workshop
And then Trump had a day off; and he got bored.“The extraordinary intertwined with the ordinary, as it should in a case like this one. As one young woman from the Upper East Side, now to be known as Juror No. 2, put it during the selection process, ‘No one is above the law.’ Let’s hope that sentiment prevails.” https://t.co/q3au4p8AAj
— George Conway (@gtconway3d) April 18, 2024
On the left:
— Ryan Goodman (@rgoodlaw) April 17, 2024
NY judge's gag order prohibiting Trump from "making ... public statements about any prospective juror or any juror in this criminal proceeding."
On the right:
Trump making public statement about prospective jurors in this criminal proceedings. pic.twitter.com/qvqsnURlUj
Trump's latest social media slip is a 'very very clear violation' of his gag order: expert https://t.co/r3qi8Z0SbY
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 18, 2024
"It is a very, very clear violation of the gag order," he told CNN's Erin Burnett on her show "Out Front." "The gag order's last provision says that Trump cannot make public statements about any prospective juror or any juror. Full stop."
Trump just made an 'attempt to intimidate jurors' on social media: CNN legal analyst https://t.co/nk4aWQFU4g
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 18, 2024
"I mean, it is just not permissible and I think prosecutors who will have already asked to have him founded contempt for other violations where he's talked about witnesses. This in many respects is much more serious because judges take the jury and the integrity of the jury as almost sacrosanct and the idea that he's intimidating the jury is something that I think Judge Merchan is going to be very concerned about."I’m old enough to remember yesterday, when Trump grumbled something one account described as barely audible, as a juror was leaving the room to. A dismissed juror. And Merchan told the lawyer (as he should do) to tell his client to watch his ass.
Agnifilo on Trump’s post: I think the judge going to go ripshit because you cannot say anything like that about a juror. pic.twitter.com/9PAKqyu8xP
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 18, 2024
By the way, what he did is not a "re-tweet," this is, with a single click reposting someone's else original post.
— S.V. Dáte (@svdate) April 18, 2024
He wrote that out, or had one of his staff or friends write it, on HIS account.
Trump is now "re-truthing" fake allegations about jurors. A full jury isn't even sworn in and he's already coming for them. pic.twitter.com/BKi0D5VeXw
— Joyce Alene (@JoyceWhiteVance) April 17, 2024
In Case You Were Wondering…
...how that came out.It didn't even last 3 hours, as the Senate voted to dismiss the impeachment charges against Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, and the trial is now officially adjourned.
— Jamie Dupree (@jamiedupree) April 17, 2024
No more votes today. Schumer: We have serious business ahead of us in the next 2 days (FISA)
Asymmetry Is A Feature, Not A Bug
It occurs to me I saw something similar in seminary.(1/X) Sorry to keep doing these, but I wanted to do one more thing about how poorly media handles the asymmetry between Trump and Democrats. This is torn directly from my real life experiences watching deans empower an abusive narcissistic sociopath...
— New York Times Pitchbot (@DougJBalloon) April 17, 2024
The New York Trial Is Already Getting Expensive
https://t.co/iPIiQMM3BD pic.twitter.com/XutIUzXppp
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 17, 2024
No Shit, Sherlock
Trump doesn’t go to the courtroom without his Secret Service team making sure it is secure. Former Presidents don’t go anywhere spontaneously. Not to Chuck-Fil-A, not to a bodega in Harlem.Just like every other Trump event like Chick-fil-A in ATL & others that are passed off as “spontaneous,” his visit to the bodega in NYC was organized & orchestrated by the NY Young Republican Club, whose members were out there leading the cheers. Story. https://t.co/gKS6kGbHkD
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 17, 2024
And They Think Court Is Boring!
I’m actually listening to this procedure on MSNBC. Hey, I’m old, I’m a lawyer, I have a very low boredom threshold. I read Kierkegaard for entertainment, for pity’s sake!IN SUM: What Schumer just did – make a constitutional point of order at the start against a Mayorkas impeachment article – is what Rand Paul did at the start of Trump's second impeachment trial.
— Ira 'Greybeard Homer' Goldman 🦆🦆🦆 (@KDbyProxy) April 17, 2024
(just, Paul didn't have the votes; Schumer does)
Receipt ⬇️https://t.co/bw07HuggEU
Restitution For Rich White Men
Agreed, except “fair trial” here means Trump is acquitted, exonerated of all other charges against him from New York courts, given the key to the city and a ticker tape parade, and declared President for Life by acclamation, term starting immediately, no take backs.There was literally a Tim Pool devotee who sat on Trump's civil trial over defamation.
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 17, 2024
Guess what, people can compartmentalize. Not all of us live our entire existence through our political views.
I know that's tough for the simple minded to grasp. https://t.co/68PnLighWI
Right After They Come Up With The Crimes Mayorkas Committed
"Morning Joe” made much of the fact the Senate had articles of impeachment for the Secretary of Homeland Security, despite the fact no high crimes or misdemeanors are alleged against him. I guess Comer figures that’s good enough, so long as the GOP has 50% plus one?Raskin: What is the crime that you want to impeach Joe Biden for? Tell America right now
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 17, 2024
Comer: You’re about to find out very soon pic.twitter.com/MFXsRVwulA
My only disappointment is that Moskowitz wasn’t there.Comer: Is it ok for China to bribe Biden’s family with $9 million?
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 17, 2024
Raskin: Thats been discredited. If Biden took a bribe, why aren’t you impeaching him?
Comer: Who says we’re not?
Raskin: I can invite Mr. Moskowitz to come back in. Do you want to move for impeachment today? pic.twitter.com/6cdC973pfJ
Raskin: We have spent millions pursuing this
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 17, 2024
Comer: That is not true. We haven’t spent hardly anything
Raskin: Then we get what we pay for because you got nothing pic.twitter.com/K4dtYbeKMh
“Old Man, Look At My Life, I’m A Lot Like You Were”
Wasn’t that the premise of “Friends”? Except I understand the unrealistic part there was getting such an apartment in NYC in the first place. I mean, at all.“I’m not voting until the economy is so good that an entry-level worker in their 20s can be absolutely assured of living alone”
— Will Stancil (@whstancil) April 17, 2024
Look, call me a troll or whatever, but I think some of the economic gloom among young people might be coming from totally unrealistic expectations pic.twitter.com/PYc5BFVUg1
“Whaddya Got?”
The Civil Rights Movement was organized and purposeful, and at least got the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act passed. We are, nearly 69 years later, reaching the nadir of the reactionary forces against those changes, but that just proves you can never declare “Mission Accomplished.”While I view this as disgusting, it is also something the Supreme Court ruled is protected speech under the First Amendment. https://t.co/VtCglHBoWx
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 17, 2024
Professor of Criminal Procedure, Trump University School of Law
"UNCONSTITUTIONAL! RICH WHITE MAN PRIVILEGE CLAUSE! I SHOULD BE ABLE TO STRIKE ALL IF MANHATTAN FROM THE JURY! AND PUT ONLY MY FAMILY MEMBERS AND ALAN WEISSELBERG THERE! UNFAIR!”Trump’s complaint about strikes is odd for multiple reasons — 1) it would make no sense for strikes to be unlimited in any criminal case; 2) his lawyers have known there would be 10 strikes for months. pic.twitter.com/vHdJ4Rmmhp
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) April 17, 2024
Tuesday, April 16, 2024
Aging Well
But if he is asleep:MacCallum: There’s two reports of Trump falling asleep in court
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
Habba: I’ve heard that report. It’s unlikely. I sat in trial after trial with him, that never happens. He’s incredibly focused pic.twitter.com/75Jd8KOoFF
If anything he's probably brutally bored," Habba said. "It's painful. They make him sit there through jury selection, the first day was procedural."Later that same day:
Habba then appeared on Newsmax hours later to field similar questions and admitted she hadn't been in the courtroom, but found the account — from New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman — a "remarkable story at best." "He reads a lot," Habba said. Habba, who defended Trump in two New York civil cases last year, once again argued that court proceedings are dull. "He's been sitting there as he's forced to, at the threat of going to jail if he's not sitting there, for what I assume would be a very mundane day," Habba said. "They are going through jury selection there were a tremendous amount of motions being heard yesterday."So how about this account?
Or the other accounts today? Just another conspiracy? Or a failure to appreciate how bored Trump is with the rest of us. It’s like he’s an arrogant super-villain, and Habba is his minion.Must’ve been sleeping a while.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
Courtroom sketch from Jane Rosenberg pic.twitter.com/VFIERlwZz9
Bodega Cats 🐈⬛
Two days of jury selection, 7 jurors selected, =“rushing this trial.”Trump: We are going to continue our fight against this judge. We think he’s totally conflicted. He’s a conflicted judge. There’s never been a judge more conflicted than this one.. We think we have a very conflicted, highly conflicted judge… he’s rushing this trial pic.twitter.com/4KXl6gQmZw
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
Does what you believe matter? See you at the hearing on the show cause order. You can tell the judge what you believe, there. See where it gets you.Reporter: Do you believe you violated the order?
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
Trump: No, I didn’t. There shouldn't be a gag order. Let me just tell you the gag order is totally unconstitutional. pic.twitter.com/cGOnYuJa15
So that’s why you went there with a Secret Service contingent?Trump speaking at a bodega: You know where the crime is? The bodegas pic.twitter.com/zDvNjsFfuA
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
You know the cameras never show the crowds. There were at least 5000 people there. But you can’t see them.Trump arrives at his rally after court. pic.twitter.com/UDwrvGfwfB
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
If I’m Ever Caught Or Killed…
...or called for jury duty, I will disavow any knowledge of this blog.Someone give me the willpower to be Juror B128 https://t.co/qty3ye9Ccc
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 16, 2024
O, The Humanities!
The judge is now STARTING to allow the lawyers to question Panel 2 at 5:00 PM when they were supposed to stop at 4:30.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
Trump is likely very understanding and tolerant of the schedule change.
Earlier today:This is the first time Trump has had to be anywhere from 9-5 in his life.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
Agnifilo then explained a quirk of jury selection rules that allows the defense and prosecutors to request an unlimited number of jurors be excused for a specific reason (for cause) but limits each side to 10 "peremptory " removals, or removals lawyers can request without a reason.
"You don't want to waste your peremptory," Agnifilo said. Which, she explained is why, "the prosecutor here did something very interesting."
The Manhattan district attorney's office didn't challenge the first 12 jurors, ultimately landing the defense with 12 difficult decisions, Agnifilo explained.
"That's a chess move on their part because it forces...the defense," she explained. " They only have ten challenges. If they don't like those jurors, and they don't get any for cause challenges, you could have two jurors right there."
Agnifilo believes this forcing of the hand will essentially make impossible Trump's primary tactic in each of his four criminal cases: delay.
"We're going to have a jury this week," she predicted. "It's going much faster than I thought."And:
Which explains the overtime. Merchan wants this case to get underway.NEW: Despite some ponderous moments, we have our first 6 jurors—and it’s only Tuesday afternoon. But we’ll need 18 total (12 jurors and 6 alternates). 1/
— Lisa Rubin (@lawofruby) April 16, 2024
Sidebars Interrupt Checking His Eyelids For Holes
🥱😂Your honor, never mind. This is boring. pic.twitter.com/F4qoMAKzx5
— Olivia Nuzzi (@Olivianuzzi) April 16, 2024
Just Ask Yourself What The GOP Had To Do With This
Breaking news: The US is on track to grow at double the rate of any other G7 country this year, according to IMF forecasts. https://t.co/aYj8HwytQj pic.twitter.com/5Secjg1yer
— Financial Times (@FT) April 16, 2024
How To Win Friends And Influence People
NEW: Not even 2 days in, Judge Merchan calls out Trump’s conduct, telling Todd Blanche “while the juror was about 12 feet from client, your client was audibly saying something in her direction….I will not have any juror intimidated in this courtroom.”
— Lisa Rubin (@lawofruby) April 16, 2024
KEEP AWAKE!
'He ain't woke': #DonSnoreleone trends as Trump court nap mockery goes into overdrivehttps://t.co/3OjPr4Ihda
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 16, 2024
Without cameras in the courtroom to confirm, MSNBC's Andrea Mitchell said Trump could be asleep or he could be "resting his eyes."Judges would also accept “Checking his eyelids for holes.” 🙄
True to his word, he ain’t woke.#DonSnoreleone pic.twitter.com/Bs861a2DQ2
— Scottacular (@Scottcrates) April 16, 2024
...but apparently not so much an assault that Trump can't sleep through it #DonSnoreLeone pic.twitter.com/uWo9N7Ed2e
— Keith Olbermann (@KeithOlbermann) April 16, 2024
And yes, potential jurors are in the room as Trump naps. 💤💤Sleepy Donald #Trump #SleepyTrump #SleepyDonald #MAGA #TrumpTrials #TrumpJury #SleepyDonny #DonSnoreleone pic.twitter.com/YsxU3XPPCq
— Clay Jones (@claytoonz) April 16, 2024
Private Cell. All I’m Sayin’..:
A testy exchange just now in court as Judge Merchan heard Trump loudly making comments towards a prospective juror and warns him that he will not tolerate his attempts to intimidate a juror. Story updated with all the latest …https://t.co/5yGA0EjYaT
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
And then:When Trump's lawyer questioned a juror about Facebook posts, the former president reacted audibly and visibly.
— Adam Klasfeld (@KlasfeldReports) April 16, 2024
After she leaves, Justice Merchan angrily warns him via his lawyer:
"I will not have any jurors intimidated in this courtroom. I want to make that crystal clear."
Trump will be outraged this evening that Rich white men can’t do whatever they want to do in America.🇺🇸Merchan rejected the for-cause challenge by Trump's defense, calling the juror's explanation "credible."
— Adam Klasfeld (@KlasfeldReports) April 16, 2024
Making The Sausage
Blanche immediately goes after Steinglass's many analogies and examples and says: "This isn't a baseball game. This is extraordinarily serious."
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
B288 doesn't have an opinion of Trump, "not in this courtroom...He will be treated like anyone else, and no one is above the law." Blanche asks about her opinion outside this case, walking into this. "I didn't even know I was walking into this," she says, and Blanche laughs.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
Blanche is now questioning the juror who's a fellow prosecutor, though in a different borough. Juror says it "boils down" to whether he can listen to the laws given by the judge. "Up to this point, [Trump's] proven innocent," he adds.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
Now B113, who said yesterday no one is above the law, not the president, not a janitor, has the mic: "What I think about [Trump] outside this room" has no bearing...If we were sitting in a bar, I'd be happy to tell you, but in this room how I feel about Trump is not important."
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
Blanche seems satisfied, so we move onto another juror who is an attorney. He says, "I was a big fan of The Apprentice when I was watching in middle school at the time," which gets a chuckle from Trump.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
All the jurors so far seem to be very reluctant to give their opinion of Trump, per Blanche's repeated question, saying it's not relevant in this courtroom or in this case.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
"I agree with the others in separating the politics and the person," says one juror.
There's a reason they don’t show this shit in the movies. But arguably the most important parts of a trial are voir dire (jury selection), and the jury charge at the other end. Two things you never see in movies, because it’s not dramatic."I find him fascinating," says another juror. "He walks into a room and just sets people off." Trump smiles and chuckles to himself.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
"Um, alright, thank you," Blanche says and the press laughs.
“Let’s You And Him Fight!”
It’s the MAGA way.He meant what he said and he said what he meant, a thug calls for violence 100 percent. https://t.co/wy0R9atnUh
— Kara Swisher (@karaswisher) April 16, 2024
Yes, this is for your own good.This came up when Justice Merchan read out the “Parker warning”—some were confused why the judge would threaten arrest for not appearing without informing the defendant of his ability to file a motion to avoid having to appear. pic.twitter.com/zaHfr09oCb
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
I think the “intelligent” element is the stumbling block here.The judge can excuse the defendant, but as @nkorpett tells me, the judge will be careful about it because the rule’s requirement is designed to protect a constitutional right. So waiving that right must be “voluntary, knowing, and intelligent.” Hence the Parker warning.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
“You’re nothing but a pack of cards!” Trump, in his own mind..@qjurecic rightly points out to me that these rules exist to protect a defendant's right to hear the case against them, confront witnesses, etc. But Trump is kind of turning that on its head by implying in this post and others that it’s unfair for Merchan to require his presence pic.twitter.com/DNlwCAvt3q
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 16, 2024
On the other hand, let him keep talking to the cameras:Keep confessing, thank you https://t.co/nQm5LQx1u3
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 16, 2024
News:
— Adam Klasfeld (@KlasfeldReports) April 16, 2024
Prosecutors release their written arguments for finding Trump in contempt for posts that they say "unquestionably" violate the gag order.
Full filing in the thread. pic.twitter.com/XdXfMYnZjB
Trumps lawyers are requesting if it's ok if he shows up in pajamas tomorrow. pic.twitter.com/eR6KGcXB7e
— GingerSpice❄️💙 (@thedesertginger) April 15, 2024
“Shh! I’m Meditating…”—Frank Zappa
Vossoughian: Trump’s eyes are closed pic.twitter.com/chIes31rHV
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
Now: Trump's head slowly dropped, his eyes closed. It jerked back upward. He adjusts himself. Then, his head droops again. He straightens up, leaning back. His head doops for a third time, he shakes his shoulders. Eyes closed still. His head drops. Finally, he pops his eyes open.
— Frank G. Runyeon (@frankrunyeon) April 16, 2024
Droopy-eyed Trump perks up in court as potential juror talks about 'The Art of the Deal'https://t.co/0iotl4YA5M
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 16, 2024
While jurors ran through the long list of questions about their lives and habits, Trump sat in his seat with his eyes closed, head slowly drooping until he snapped his eyes open — at least twice," The Huffington Post reported Tuesday.
But a juror's mention of "The Art of the Deal" seemed to wake the former president.
"Trump is leaning back and reading the questionnaire an inch from his face. He looks tired again, sometimes struggling to keep heavy eyelids open, and perked up when the last potential juror mentioned 'The Art of the Deal,'" Molly Crane-Newman wrote for The New York Daily News.
"Just now Trump smiles and nods as a Jewish prospective juror says he has read two of his books "Art of the Deal" and "How to Get Rich," posted reporter Henry Rosoff of Pix11.Told ya. Like a dog, he perks up when he hears his name.
Rich White Man Privilege Is A Powerful Force…
...in America.🇺🇸“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it.”
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
- Joseph Goebbels pic.twitter.com/WrlrOnAZHv
Megalomania Is Not A Presidential Attribute
Gonna be interesting to see what Biden/Harris do with this.Good morning, sunshine! pic.twitter.com/GxFF6Jsory
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
“I’M A RICH WHITE MAN AND I’M NOT GETTING EVERYTHING I WANT!”
'Take off the Gag Order!' Trump spits hot rage at Judge Merchan in early morning ranthttps://t.co/cuaKkO9tdB
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 16, 2024
"This conflicted, Trump Hating Judge won’t let me respond to people that are on TV lying and spewing hate all day long," said the former president, who was impeached twice during his lone term in office and has since been indicted on criminal charges in four different jurisdictions. "He is running rough shod over my lawyers and legal team. The New York System of 'Justice' is being decimated by critics from all over the World. I want to speak, or at least be able respond. Election Interference! RIGGED, UNCONSTITUTIONAL TRIAL! Take off the Gag Order!!!"Welcome to a criminal jury trial, Donnie.
As Long As We’re Weeping Crocodile Tears 🐊
She’s heart-broken about Barron’s graduation. How does she feel about none of Trump’s children, or Barron’s mother, showing up for the trial? A trial about Trump sleeping with two different women while Melania was pregnant with Barron.What a joke. This whole thing is a hoax. pic.twitter.com/lfMFPHo3JL
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
🐊I have rarely seen a defendant facing trial alone with no family, at least one person, in the courtroom for him. It's a sad commentary for a former president with four grown children & a wife, all of whom seem to have deserted him in the moment.
— Joyce Alene (@JoyceWhiteVance) April 16, 2024
Monday, April 15, 2024
Scrapping Up
Mee-ow!Haberman: I noticed that he made a pretty specific stare at me and walked out of the room.. If anyone falls asleep who is a criminal defendant in a case, we're going to report on it. But he doesn't like when such things are reported… pic.twitter.com/OANWOTmJUR
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
I thought Newt was an historian now.Gingrich: I think we ought to go back and learn the lessons of the 1930s. FDR was faced with a Nazi effort inside the US. They locked people up… pic.twitter.com/0ESPd26f1R
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
I guess not.Hey @newtgingrich FYI, this is a photo of 20,000 American Nazis sympathizers meeting at Madison Square Garden NYC in 1939. The only person arrested was Isadore Greenbaum, a Jewish American who charged the stage in protest of the Nazi rally. pic.twitter.com/dlBxAmwpeY
— Jeffrey Evan Gold (@jeffgoldesq) April 16, 2024
Is she a lawyer? There is no due process right for a party to attend a Supreme Court argument.Habba: Not even allowing a person due process, the right to go sit in front of the supreme court and hear a case that determines many lawsuits that are currently against President Trump on immunity… pic.twitter.com/ogzAxYr52S
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
No wonder Trump likes her. She is as ignorant as he is. And as much a liar.Habba: You’re not even allowing a father attend his son's graduation? And let’s not forget Passover. Ok? Observing Jews have a right to go and— and— and pray to who they want pic.twitter.com/sUsXRCb0Xs
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 16, 2024
I’m not even touching the issue of what God Jews pray to. I’m sure she and Trump are equally ignorant there, too.The judge said he wouldn’t rule on the graduation yet.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
The judge said they would take both the first 2 days and the last 2 days of Passover off.
The judge is taking every Wednesday off.
No other defendant in the country would get coddled like this.
And they’re still crying. https://t.co/7xGWj2FAH9
He’ll drop it like a bad habit if there aren’t any Orthodox Jews in the jury. Besides:The Trump campaign is bringing up the Passover issue because they believe that Orthodox Jews in NYC are mostly Trump supporters so they want some on the jury. That was on right wing social media yesterday.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
Trump really is his own worst enemy. And a prime example of rich white man privilege. Even as the walls come tumbling down.Reading between the lines, what Merchan was saying is if you stop violating the gag order, behave yourself in the courtroom, stop filing frivolous motions, mark exhibits as ordered, don’t constantly make excuses to delay, & show up on time, I’ll consider your graduation request.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
hehBy Day 3 Trump’s lawyers will be asking the judge to put a gag order on Trump to prevent him from talking to them.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
Seems reasonable.Can they just televise the testimony of the Playboy model when she talks about the affair she had with Trump for a year during Melania’s entire pregnancy. Just that part and I’m good.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 16, 2024
I was hoping we’d get at least one bronzer report today. I do wonder what the impact on the jury is going to be.What does a grown man slather this ridiculous makeup on his face? It’s like he’s Judy Garland or something. pic.twitter.com/sjxEbmP3It
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) April 16, 2024
In the four weeks after the Hur report, the New York Times wrote 30 stories on Biden’s age.
— Eric Schultz (@EricSchultz) April 15, 2024
Interested to see how many they write on this. https://t.co/DgEr0HFWlT
Donald Trump repeatedly fell asleep during today’s trial proceedings, raising alarms about Biden’s vigor and stamina.
— New York Times Pitchbot (@DougJBalloon) April 15, 2024
All Roads Lead To…
'That opens the door': Lawyer uncovers key problem with Trump's hush money defense https://t.co/NVWprcgnMB
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 16, 2024
…Trump’s testimony.
The catch and kill scheme came from Trump; not Stormy Daniels. It came from Trump, and he used Michael Cohen to implement it."Then once you have the agreement? What's it for? ...To conceal the agreement to unlawfully influence the 2016 election," Wiley said. "Why would Michael Cohen do that? How does he benefit from that?"Cui bono, indeed? Unless, of course, you think the whole world conspires against you. But that’s hardly a legal defense.
Wiley then answered herself by arguing Cohen did not benefit. "Donald Trump is the one who benefitted," Wiley said.
She then detailed the other witnesses who back Cohen's narrative.
"Witnesses we believe will be lined up are the ones like Hope Hicks, who was on the campaign," Wiley said. "We know that the District Attorney is looking to establish Hope Hicks as a campaign operative actively and consistently in communication with Michael Cohen, including a call that Donald Trump was on."
In comparison, there's only one witness who can testify to Trump's state of mind and it's a person whose testimony could prove fatal to his defense, Wiley argued.
"The defense can suggest that this is for, by Michael Cohen and only in his own interest, which is kind of hard to do — unless Donald Trump tries to say, "It was all about Melania, I was just worried about Melania,'" Wiley argued. "But how do you get that evidence in?
"He'd have to take the stand, and as we know, the minute he would do that, which is very hard to imagine happening, that opens the door for the prosecution to eat his lunch."There it is. Not inevitable; but very hard to see how they put on a defense otherwise. Which is to say, very hard to see how they put on a defense at all.
What’s Coming
And during the pregnancy, he was having a different affair:Remember that the son Trump is referring to below was born to him and his wife Melania just four months before he allegedly began his affair with a porn star. https://t.co/KmYrQobvmL
— Tim O'Brien (@TimOBrien) April 16, 2024
Trump is crying about supposedly having to miss Barron’s graduation when the state is introducing evidence that he was having an affair with a Playboy model the entire time Melania was pregnant.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
And that was before Stormy.
We won’t be seeing Melania on the campaign trail.
Except Trump approached Daniels in the aftermath of the Access Hollywood tape. That tape is going to be presented in evidence (via transcript from the Carroll cases), and Daniels is going to testify. Funny thing about court: only evidence matters. Nothing Ingraham says here is going to be true. And reports from the court will prove it. Trump wasn’t trying to put the episode behind him. He was trying to win the election.Wait, is Ingraham admitting that Trump had the affair?
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 16, 2024
Because Trump certainly hasn't admitted that. https://t.co/g1g64FoEx0
How To Please Your Client And Piss Off The Judge
IOW: Lose.I spoke too soon: Blanche says that the campaign has taken pains to schedule events on Wednesdays and asks Merchan if Trump be excused from any hearings that take place on Wednesdays, when the jury is in recess. Merchan says he will take this into consideration.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 15, 2024
Gonna be a long six weeks for somebody.Blanche continues, but Merchan fires at him: "You don't think we should be here at all right now?" Then says "let's move along from that objection. I've already ruled on that." Finally, at 4:39, all rise as Merchan leaves the bench.
— Tyler McBrien (@TylerMcBrien) April 15, 2024
Ok, now I definitely need some air. Til tmrw!
Name them. Name your son, for that matter.Trump: We had some amazing things happen today. As you know, my son is graduating from high school. It looks like the judge will not let me go to the graduation of my son who's worked very, very hard and he is a great student. pic.twitter.com/XKqHAnWxwa
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 15, 2024
Tom Fitton. Alina Habba. Jonathan Turley. All the scholars.Trump: If you read all of the legal pundits, all of the legal scholars, there’s not one that I see that said that this is a case that should be brought for trial.. We’re not going to be given a fair trial pic.twitter.com/6Yzib8v3kr
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 15, 2024
In matters of conduct of this trial, Merchan is superior.Trump complains that judges won’t allow ‘us’ to go to The Supreme Court hearing on immunity: He thinks he’s superior to The Supreme Court pic.twitter.com/CL8zzs6v1i
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 15, 2024
Rich white man privilege. Quick, somebody ask him how many campaign events he’s attended in the past six weeks. 1? 2?Trump: That I can’t go to my son’s graduation or that I can’t go to The US Supreme Court… that I’m not in Georgia or Florida or North Carolina campaigning like I should be… pic.twitter.com/HPiI54oMhc
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 15, 2024
He wouldn’t understand three words said at the arguments. He doesn’t need to be there, except maybe to get in his lawyer’s face and tell him to fight harder.He’s just naming random places he would also be dozing off at https://t.co/I3ph6Gs9Rr
— Acyn (@Acyn) April 15, 2024
BREAKING!
Also, too, as well.Update
— Adam Klasfeld (@KlasfeldReports) April 15, 2024
Justice Merchan bumped up the hearing date to consider whether to hold Trump in contempt for alleged violations of his gag order.
It's now on Tuesday, April 23 at 9:30 a.m. ET, per pool.
Trump lawyer slapped down after complaining to judge about deadlinehttps://t.co/4Q3NRewyFQ
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 15, 2024
New York City Judge Juan Merchan set the deadline Monday after Assistant District Attorney Josh Steinglass said Trump's attorneys had failed to turn over any of the exhibits they plan to use in the former president's defense, according to Law 360 reporter Stewart Bishop.
Trump's legal team was ordered to do so back in February, Bishop notes.
This demand spurred outrage from Todd Blanche, who complained to Merchan that 24 hours was not enough time to prepare the hand-over amid ongoing jury selection preparation, according to Bishop.
It was a wry Merchan that reminded Trump of their many filings delivered in the weeks before the trial — which include multiple failed efforts to delay the trial and toss the charges — and one whirlwind 30-minute period that saw Trump's lawyers file three motions.
“The way you choose to use your time is your business,” Merchan reportedly told Blanche.Coincidence? I think not!
Six more weeks.Per CBS/@KatrinaSari, "Trump’s eyes are closed and arms crossed as the judge instructs the jury. When Merchan said it’s his job to conduct a fair and impartial trial, Trump opened his eyes and smirked."
— Robert Costa (@costareports) April 15, 2024
And some of that time will be jury selection.Per pool:
— Adam Klasfeld (@KlasfeldReports) April 15, 2024
"At least nine more prospective jurors were excused after raising their hand when Judge Merchan asked if they could not serve for any other reason. Those reasons were not disclosed. That leaves ~34 jurors of the 96 who entered court in the initial panel."
If Trump is too old to stay awake for his trial for committing financial fraud to cover up his cover up of fucking a porn star, he's too old to be President.
— emptywheel (@emptywheel) April 15, 2024
/NYT
"STOP HELPING!"Unaware that Trump has been falling asleep during the trial, this guy outside the courthouse says he made Trump a MAGA hammock and it was such a hit that he is now selling them. pic.twitter.com/uLPZJW5CJQ
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
Really curious to see how long that lasts. This, too:Classic example of today's GOP right here... https://t.co/F7pjDx5MCp
— Amy McGrath (@AmyMcGrathKY) April 15, 2024
'Getting into his lawyer's face': Trump pushes attorney to 'fight harder' in trialhttps://t.co/BVtZVTL8Dl
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 15, 2024
Justice [Juan] Merchan tells Trump’s attorneys they have 24 hours to do so, or such evidence will be precluded from use," reported Law360's Stewart Bishop. "Trump counsel Todd Blanche complains, says that’s not enough time, what with jury selection and all."
That is the situation that appeared to set Trump off.
"This is where it gets interesting," said MSNBC's Katy Tur reading an update from inside the courtroom. "Donald Trump is now personally getting involved here. He's pushing Todd Blanche — his lawyer — to fight harder about these documents and this compliance saying that they need more time."
She turned to Catherine A. Christian, a 30-year veteran of the Manhattan D.A.'s office.
"What do you make of Donald Trump getting into this, Catherine? Getting up and telling his — or getting into his lawyer's face and telling him that he needs to fight — to fight harder?" Tur asked.
"It's going to be a long trial for Mr. Blanche because he is out of control. He is one of those clients that you hope to not have because if he's acting this way now, he's going to do it throughout the trial," she said.That was the defense requirement to produce documents, which they should have done in February.
Six weeks.SleepyDon has the sads https://t.co/cvyHplsKR8
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) April 15, 2024
Playing A Lawyer For Trump
It isn’t just about being a Presidential candidate. It’s more basic. It’s about rich, white man privilege.Trump’s Official Spokesperson.
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
This also the law for every single criminal defendant in every single criminal trial in the history of the United States. pic.twitter.com/WHxBa9fL5q
Highlights
Judge Merchan sets a hearing for April 24 on whether Trump will be held in contempt for violating the gag order. https://t.co/XDUhpMA3v3
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
Alina Habba says that jury selection in the trial today is rigged. https://t.co/eERBHmvG8b
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
Trump did not appear to be happy when Judge Merchan introduced him to the prospective jurors as “Mister Donald Trump.”https://t.co/XDUhpMA3v3
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
Ms. Haberman’s description was pretty clear….Sleepy Don https://t.co/kXedaZCrvn
— Ron Filipkowski (@RonFilipkowski) April 15, 2024
'Pain in the neck': CNN expert reacts to Trump's unusual courtroom requesthttps://t.co/mnTqkhMwBG
— Raw Story (@RawStory) April 15, 2024
The former president asked Judge Juan Merchan to allow him to stand beside the bench to listen in on one-on-one conversations with individuals who might be tasked with deciding on whether to convict Trump of falsifying business records to conceal payments that flowed to adult movie actress Stormy Daniels in an effort to cover up an affair,
CNN legal analyst Paula Reid said the request put his attorneys in a difficult spot.
"He's the client from hell, right?" Reid said. "He's a pain in the neck. I'm sure that his lawyers would prefer that he not be there, so that they will be free to make the legal arguments they need to make and not necessarily be performing for an audience of one."
Judges also hold sidebar conversations at the bench with attorneys so jurors are unable to hear as they work out legal issues related to the case, and Trump wants to be present for those, as well.
"Usually the sidebar conversations are issues that they want to resolve outside the presence of the jury or, in this case today, potential jurors," Reid said.
"So these are issues that are sensitive and may have to deal with some evidence that's being brought up, an objection that is made, and I'm told from my sources that we can expect throughout this case, there will likely be a lot of objections, a lot of sidebars, because the defense is, they are completely focused on preserving every possible issue for appeal."Trump won’t have the foggiest fucking notion what they’re discussing in those sidebars. Like a dog, he’ll only hear his name being mentioned. And he’ll pester his lawyers later with what Tom Fitton says they shoulda done.