Adventus

"The central doctrine of Christianity, then, is not that God is a bastard. It is, in the words of the late Dominican theologian Herbert McCabe, that if you don’t love you’re dead, and if you do, they’ll kill you."--Terry Eagleton

"It is impossible for me to say in my book one word about all that music has meant in my life. How then can I hope to be understood?--Ludwig Wittgenstein

“The opposite of poverty is not wealth; the opposite of poverty is justice."--Bryan Stevenson

Thursday, August 14, 2014

Nothing to do with Bill Murry or Scarlett Johansson....

The Gift of Scarlett Johansson 
The French title "Donner la mort" plays on the ordinary sense of donner, meaning "to give," and the idiomatic sense of this expression, which is "to put to death," as in se donner la mort, "to commit suicide."  In translating Derrida's title with the noun phrase I seek to have heard in it (or behind it) the English expression "kiss of death."  In the text I have tried to flow the idea of "giving" or "granting" wherever possible, but I have used "to put to death" when comprehensibility so demands, sometimes adding the French for mnemonic purposes.  Whenever "to put to death" is used, however, the reader should also hear the sense of "giving."

--Translator's Preface, The Gift of Death by Jacques Derrida, tr. David Wills, Chicago:  The University of Chicago Press, 1995.

I start there because this is a fascinating problem in translation:

The Simon Wiesenthal Center, a well-known Jewish group, has sent a formal requestto France’s interior minister kindly requesting that the country rename a small hamlet south of Paris called La-mort-aux-Juifs, which, of course, translates to Death to Jews. Oh.

The French, however, declined to take up the suggestion:

Marie-Elizabeth Secretand, the deputy mayor of Courtemaux, the village that has jurisdiction over the hamlet, responded in the most blasé way: “It’s ridiculous. This name has always existed … No one has anything against the Jews, of course. It doesn’t surprise me that this is coming up again.

“Why change a name that goes back to the Middle Ages or even further?” she continued. “A previous municipal council, at least 20 years ago, already refused to change the name of this hamlet, which consists of a farm and two houses.”
It turns out the French aren't being insensitive or anti-semitic; the problem is in the translation:

La-mort-aux-Juifs has been thus named since the 16th century (and not the middle ages as Ms Secretand claimed) when Jews rose up against the local lord's excessive taxes and were slaughtered by his troops where the hamlet stands now.


La-mort-aux-Juifs Does Not Translate "Death to Jews": it translates as "Jews died here" or, if you want to be less literal and more accurate "The final resting place of Jews".

And:

As a person born, raised, and educated in France, I can say that the interpretation of the Simon Wiesenthal Center is most erroneous. "Mort aux..." is an injunction to carry "death to...," whereas with the article "la" in front, it becomes a simple statement of fact. 
So, the Simon Wiesentahl Center, back to French 101...
You see something similar in the translator's quote above:  donner le mort is "to give death," but "se donner le mort" is "to put to death."  "Mort aux" is "death to...."; "la mort aux" is "the death of."   As the first commenter above further noted:

By the way, claiming that the historical context is irrelevant is, quite frankly insulting to the people who died here: the toponym is literally the Only thing that publicly reminds people that Jews were slaughtered by a petty lordling: Take that away, and the only remaining references will in dusty old historical chronicles of the Orléanais.
In history especially, ironies abound; and history is always longer, and more complicated, than just the portion you know.

3 Comments:

Blogger June Butler said...

Seems to me, the translator of Derrida takes a great liberty in changing the meaning of the idiomatic "donner la mort" from "to put to death" to "the gift of death". The idiom was around long before Derrida wrote his book. IMO, "kiss of death" means something entirely different from "to put to death", though perhaps I'm being too literal. Also, the plain meaning of "se donner la mort" is "to commit suicide".

I understand perfectly that La-mort-aux-Juifs Does Not Translate "Death to Jews". By no means am I an expert in translating French, but I agree with whoever said "the Simon Wiesenthal Center is most erroneous".

2:04 PM  
Blogger Rmj said...

Derrida likes to play with words, so "donner la mort" may well come off in his meditation as a "gift of death."

Then again, if it doesn't, that might clear up several problems I've always had with that essay.

I really should learn French.....

3:06 PM  
Blogger June Butler said...

In my old copy (50-plus years) of Cassell's French-English dictionary, one of the alternate definitions of "donner" besides "to give" is "to cause", which is perhaps the root of the idiom "donner la mort" meaning "to put to death".

Of course, I don't know for certain, but this is fascinating stuff. I should have majored in a foreign language, but Loyola didn't offer such a major, and Loyola was where I had to be, because I had a scholarship.

3:35 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home