Adventus

"The central doctrine of Christianity, then, is not that God is a bastard. It is, in the words of the late Dominican theologian Herbert McCabe, that if you don’t love you’re dead, and if you do, they’ll kill you."--Terry Eagleton

"It is impossible for me to say in my book one word about all that music has meant in my life. How then can I hope to be understood?--Ludwig Wittgenstein

“The opposite of poverty is not wealth; the opposite of poverty is justice."--Bryan Stevenson

Sunday, April 06, 2014

"You know I'm strong and holy, I must do what I've been told"



In light of the complaints about the story of Noah recently, I was listening to Cohen's "Story of Isaac" and I heard it in a new light:

You who build these altars now
To sacrifice these children,
You must not do it any more.
A scheme is not a vision
And you never have been tempted
By a demon or a god.
You who stand above them now,
Your hatchets blunt and bloody,
You were not there before,
When I lay upon a mountain
And my father's hand was trembling
With the beauty of the world.

We speak, as Barbara Ehrenreich does, of morality being "only human."  This is human morality:  to send young people to war; to have them return broken in body and mind.  Rachel Maddow reported the other night on soldiers returning from Iraq with ruined knees and injuries unrelated to combat, but brought on by wearing heavy body armor.  The sheer weight of what protected them from bullets and IED's has broken their bodies, has left young men with the knees of old men, have destroyed cartilage and bone.  And for what?  They will live with those injuries the rest of their lives; even if the VA (hah!) gives them all the care they need and deserve, they will need and deserve care because we built the altar upon which they were sacrificed.

A scheme is not a vision.  Perhaps if it has been from God, it would have been better.  Perhaps not.  Too many wars have been justified as being commanded by God.  But the difference between that and a God who commands Abraham to sacrifice a son, or tells Noah the world will end in water?

I think the difference is in the complaint, more than in the purpose of either story.  Context matters, and the context of the story of Noah makes it a different story than when recounted by Bill Maher.  Be that as it may, critiques of these stories tend to come from a place of privilege; especially when we place them in the context of human affairs, as Cohen does here.  Bill Maher has never had to face the draft or fear death and destruction from the skies.  What does he know of evil or injustice or random death and destruction on the scale the U.S. can unleash it on another country?  Afghanistan was no paradise before the U.S. invasion, but has it really improved under our military?  Iraq was no Garden of Eden under Saddam, but is life there immeasurably better now?  We stand above both countries, our hatchets blunt and bloody; and we were not there before, when Isaac lay upon a mountain.  Who are we to say we were right, God was wrong?  Abstract deaths in stories distress us, but concrete deaths in other countries are mere abstractions?

Is this merely human morality?  And if it is, is there no better morality available?  If you are used to being in charge of the world (white Americans in particular; or white male Americans, if you want to be more particular) the stories of Noah and Abraham are perhaps more appalling than they are to people accustomed to being killed by the world; by flood or famine or fire or war or soldiers or....

Neither position changes the morality or immorality of the stories, nor even the difficulty of the stories.  But to complain that God is psychotic to kill everyone, or order the death of one child, when we actively support the deaths of thousands of children even as they inflict death on millions of children, is to miss the privilege of our position in all this criticism.

3 Comments:

Blogger The Thought Criminal said...

People here like to think we don't practice child sacrifice constantly. How about parents who, with full knowledge of the rate of concussions not to mention the string of deaths going back to the beginning of the "sport" encourage their sons to play football from the cradle? Or to go into the military. How about the kewl guys who promote drinking or taking drugs as a kewl act? Or who romanticize prostitution and pornography even as it kills and destroys its victims body and soul?

This country is rife with child sacrifice, from its most mainstream lily white football and military and gun - and let's not forget guns and the sekund amendment - worshiping to those who encourage the gangsta model of homicidal and suicidal depravity, especially for young people who are not white and the pro-porn-prostitution, sex-pos pseudo-left who are willing to sacrifice enormous numbers of people on the altar to the First Amendment are all guilty of acts of human sacrifice that no angel stops at the crucial moment. And the same people who snark about some stupid Hollywood biblical epic or who give the garbled, distorted, inaccurate neo-atheist line on Abraham and Isaac (most of them seem to believe that Isaac was sacrificed) and fail to understand that it was about a God who ended human sacrifice while it was practiced all over the world, almost all of those same people are kewl with it.

6:03 AM  
Blogger alberich said...

is to miss the privilege of our position in all this criticism.

I sometimes feel a similar way about certain elements of the left who make quite cogent critiques of privilage and then forget their own privilage when they declare certain groups "privilaged" and certain groups "under-privilaged". Not sure how this connects so well to your excellent post, but somehow thinking of privilage.

Anyway:

the stories of Noah and Abraham are perhaps more appalling than they are to people accustomed to being killed by the world; by flood or famine or fire or war or soldiers or....

Yes. For example, the Akedah (Binding of Isaac) took on a much different perspective for those who were persecuted for merely being Jewish.

Also what The Thought Criminal said. Of course it works both ways, it's not only those who encourage a certain "gangsta" model (for fun and profit) but also those who would dismiss children, struggling to survive in poverty as "gangstas" and be more than willing to sacrifice them for "law and order", etc.

9:41 AM  
Blogger The Thought Criminal said...

Yes, what Alberich aid. I saw a comment a couple of weeks back by someone condemning Amazon.com when that piece about their brutal treatment of workers came out and everyone was saying they'd never shop there until they reformed. Then, late last week, the same person was recommending a good bargain to be had at Amazon.com.

The prison-judicial-industrial complex is something I address, sort of, in my post today at my blog.

2:48 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home