Tuesday, July 15, 2014

Welcome to the long, strange trip it's been....


So, this morning, I read this, got this far:

One reason is that the Bible actually gives two different sets of Ten Commandments, and they don’t match. In Exodus 20, Moses comes down from Mount Sinai with a set of stone tablets. (This is the most popular version.) Then he gets mad and smashes them and has to go back up and get another set. And God says, “Hew thee two tables of stone like unto the first: and I will write upon these tables the words that were in the first tables, which thou brakest.” (Exodus 34:1). But then, apparently, God can’t resist tweaking them a little. Ok, a lot.

and thought:  "Hey, wait a minute,"  and pulled a Bible off my shelf. Quicker than Google, I was browsing Exodus.  My suspicions confirmed (and against my better judgment) I left a comment:


Um, if you're gonna write about it, you might want to read Exodus, rather than watch the Charlton Heston movie.
The so-called Decalogue is delivered in Exodus 20: 1-17.  The catalogue of laws is interrupted by the terror of the people at the theophany (basically a huge thunderstorm) taking place atop Sinai.  The people speak to Moses (which is weird, isn't he on the mountain?), and then God goes back to delivering laws, of which the Decalogue is only the first ten.  The laws go on until Exodus 23:19, and then there's a longer passage about a ritual (I won't even bother with what it's for).  It's in Exodus 32:19 that Moses destroys the tablets with ALL the law (not just the first 10; again, that's DeMille, not Exodus), and so gets a new set starting in Exodus 34.
And I suspect a bit of historical scholarship would expose the importance of the Decalogue to Christians as of recent, Protestant vintage, not something going back to the 1st century, as I don't recall any mention of it in the book of Acts or the letters of Paul.
Which would kind of shift the whole "Christians get it all wrong" thesis of this article to "some Christians of more recent vintage," and then maybe we could say which ones, and why.  Or is a gross generalization that doesn't really account for anything except your preferred conclusion, based largely on ignorance, not insight, for only one acceptable outcome?









@Adventus ...or we can conclude the bible is a veritable Rorschach test, with each reader coming to his or her own conclusions.

Frankly, your analysis of the bible seems as misguided as those of the writer of this piece.  




@Adventus Whatever. The entire thing is irrelevant fiction. Parsing irrelevant fictions is a waste of time and energy that could be better spent learning how to be a decent human being.








@Aunt Messy @Adventus Thank you, Aunt Messy!  I have never understood why the heck people "religiously" attend "Bible Study" classses - for what?  It is a lengthy (some might say tedious), frequently violent, misogynist,  series of parables and stories about some vengeful deity who advocates all sorts of mayhem for misbehavior and "forgetting him".  Whatever happened to "live and let live"?  How about the famous Rodney King jeremiad: "Can't we all just get along?"  




@Aunt Messy @Adventus

Fiction sure - irrelevant - um - not to the hundreds of millions of practicing religionists.








@Tom A @Aunt Messy @Adventus So? It's not like we're talking about rationality here. A whole lot of people refuse to grovel in front of a Roman torture device, too. 

It's ONLY relevant to believers. Those of us that are rational don't need to waste our time figuring out WHAT they believe, we only need to make them irrelevant to the world at large.

So far, they're managing to self-destruct all on their own, anyway.




@Aunt Messy @Adventus And parsing comments is a better way to spend your time?

It's a simple matter:  it's called reading comprehension.  Nothing to do with the content, merely to do with accuracy in reporting on the content.
More trouble than it's worth to divide that up or change the formatting, but that's what got left while I was away. My belated response is the penultimate comment, there; but you get the drift.  Something there is about topics religious which deranges the mind; or at least makes commenters see all kinds of monsters drooling under the bed.

I really don't get it. My only comment was on the accuracy of the reporting of what Exodus said; not on the accuracy of Exodus as history of events, nor the analysis in the article (which is pretty piss poor, and as I mentioned in passing, assumes a lot about the history of Christianity which I'm not sure is valid.).

The reigning assumption is that all Christians are fundamentalists, and have been since Paul died (I as often see Paul blamed for messing up Christianity as I see the "Old Testament" labelled a book full of a vengeful and wrathful God, and nothing like Jesus; which is so illiterate it's downright sad).  Point out that "the Fundamentals" were written in the early 20th century, and the monkeys hoot and fling poo at you.  (I know, I know, it's a tiresome metaphor by now, but read those comments again and tell me if you don't think "Welcome to the Monkey House" is a phrase that springs to mind).

I know better than to bother; and I report on it to clear it out of my mind.  Something even odder happened to me today, which merits its own post.  Just consider these diary entries on what a long, strange trip it's been.

Monday, July 14, 2014

You got your chocolate in my peanut butter!


It's an otherwise busy week in which I won't get much done, so I might as well let this go; it may be the last thing I post for a week, and in part it's inspired by this post at Thought Criminal, if only because the worship of science one sees on the intertubes is a truly appalling thing.

The latest consideration at Salon is whether Nietzsche predicted the correct cosmological theory (although I think the Father of the Ubermensch is just click bait in the headline).   I won't even comment on how much Western science is a construct of a certain culture with normative values that aren't necessarily handed down from Nature anymore than Moses got the law verbatim from the hand of God on Sinai (so it's no surprise the Big Bang Theory sounds vaguely Christian, or the alternative model is distinctly Hindu).  Indeed, the very idea that science is not a pure construct of truth akin to the gospel according to fundamentalists has prompted some really ludicrous comments, viz:

When involved in a discussion of cutting-edge astrophysics, introducing Hindu or Buddhist cosmologies makes as much sense as introducing Creationism when discussing evolution.  It isn't science, so it belongs elsewhere. 

Go wherever you want with that, but my first thought was that science is heilege, holy, and so must remain pure and apart from anything that is not science, such as philosophy (don't tell this commenter that science IS a philosophy, he'll burn you at the stake as a heretic!) or religion.  The latter clearly have no place in the discussion of the holy of holies.  It shouldn't even be allowed on the grounds of the temple.

Seriously, these guys are as bad as the fundamentalists they caricature.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

"I'm not sure what it means...."

Because sometimes you need a buddy....

This is fascinating.  It may even make me change my attitude toward Burwell.  Then again, it ends here:

What remains, as Clifford Geertz reminds us, is for us to work on creating new fictions together, political, legal and religious:

The primary question . . . now that nobody is leaving anybody else alone and isn’t ever going to, is not whether everything is going to come seamlessly together or whether, contrariwise, we are all going to persist sequestered in our separate prejudices. It is whether human beings are going to be able . . . to imagine principled lives they can practicably lead.
Judges cannot do this work.

Which kind of undermines Burwell, and certainly undermines any possible legislative or even legal solution to the conundrum of what is called in the article "Big 'R' religion."

I cannot summarize the argument; it's too subtle for that, I'd do it damage.  I can focus on a few key points, by drawing out quotes:

You cannot both celebrate religious freedom and deny it to those whose religion you don’t like. Human history supports the idea that religion, small “r” religion, is a nearly ubiquitous and perhaps necessary part of human culture. Big “R” Religion, on the other hand, the Religion that is protected in constitutions and human rights law under liberal political theory, is not. Big “R” Religion is a modern invention, an invention designed to separate good religion from bad religion, orthodoxy from heresy — an invention whose legal and political use has arguably reached the end of its useful life.

That lays the groundwork, though I must say not as clearly as I would like.  The distinction between "Big 'R' Religion" and "small 'r' religion" is never as clear as it could be, but the distinction lies here:

That American religion is involved in business and obsessed with sex is not news. What is surprising is that those who object to this kind of religion continue to hold on to a faith in the idea that religious freedom means protection only for the kind of religion they like, the private, individualized, progressive kind.

There:  religion that is "private, individualized, and progressive" is acceptable; religion that is not, needs to go back to church and remain private and individualized, even if it can't (or won't) be progressive.  In the extreme formulations usually encountered in comments, all religion must be private and individualized, and no religion can claim to be progressive, because it is an offense against reason.

But this is the heart of the matter; and here, I think, the argument becomes almost unassailable:

The notion that religion exists and can be regulated without being defined is a fiction at the heart of religious freedom protection. Legal fictions — such as the idea that corporations are persons — are, of course, necessary to law. For legal scholars as diverse as Henry Maine and Lon Fuller, the capacity of legal language to finesse the facts could be understood as making legal flexibility and progress possible. The startling unbelievability of legal fictions can also focus our attention on the limits of legal language in a salutary way. Yet legal fictions can be stretched too far. They can become nothing more than lies.
Fictions, despite the more literal minded atheists and logical positivists one encounters on-line, are necessary to human existence.  But we don't need to go far afield to establish this:

Religion also specializes in fiction. It is not just the corporation that has fictional legal personality. So does the church. Justice Ginsburg objects to free exercise protection being extended to “artificial entities,” referring to corporations, but religious freedom is all about protecting artificial identities. The church is an imagined artificial entity; so are gods and demons. The church is the body of Christ in orthodox Christian theology; like the sovereign, it is the quintessential legal fiction, as we learn from Ernst H. Kantorowicz in “The King’s Two Bodies

We need fictions to live. But when the church and the state went their separate ways — when the church was disestablished — the intimate articulation of political, legal and religious fictions lost their logic on a national scale. They no longer recognize one another. The legal and religious fictions of religious freedom have become lies designed to extend the life of the impossible idea that church and state can still work together after disestablishment. There is no neutral place from which to distinguish the religious from the non-religious. There is no shared understanding of what religion, big “R” Religion, is. Let’s stop talking about big “R” Religion.

I've left out most of the discussion of Burwell and the dissent in the Wheaton College temporary injunction order.  The critiques of Ginsberg and Sotomayor are insightful, and perhaps decisive.  I haven't decided yet.

But this is definitely food for thought.....

Wednesday, July 09, 2014

MORE COWBELL!!!!


It seems the President, in Poe's felicitous phrase, is trying to out-Herod Herod.  According to Salon, Obama has done nothing but increase enforcement of immigration laws, with the result that " net migration from our southern neighbor [Mexico] has fallen to zero.  Of course, you wouldn't know that, from the fear mongering about how overrun our borders are now.

And the current crisis, the result of a law dating back to 2008, which was meant to be humane:

 a 2008 law passed under George W. Bush requires that children from non-bordering countries be handed over to the Department of Health and Human Services for care and then go before a judge. The reasoning behind this is that, unlike with Mexican children who can be handed over safely to officials from their home country at the border, that isn’t possible with kids who hail from farther away.

Has prompted this response from the Administration:  "Obama was asking for the authority to treat kids from Central America the same as those from neighboring countries."

Fortunately, that didn't go anywhere.  But still, the children must go:


the White House announced it was asking Congress for $3.7 billion for more border patrol agents, immigration judges, detention facilities, and aerial surveillance. “It is a priority for us to make sure that it is both clear to people in the country that we will remove children,” said a White House official. “And that we in fact do that much more swiftly and efficiently than we are doing now.”

I could wish that Obama remembered his UCC roots (such as they apparently were; or were not); and that Jeremiah Wright were keeping good on his promise to tell the President when he was wrong:

On Tuesday, dozens of congregations from the Southern California Nevada Conference of the UCC will be represented in a faith-based delegation that will travel to Naval Base Ventura County in Oxnard, Calif., that is currently housing hundreds of migrant children. Organized by the National Day Laborer Organizing Network and the United Methodist Church, the group will seek entrance into the naval base to ensure transparency and oversight at the facility, assess its conditions, and advocate for the children being held inside.

"Once we hear back from the delegation in Ventura, we will know more about the need is there and how we can assist," said Keith Clark, executive associate conference minister of the Southern California Nevada Conference. "It's a situation where we will have to assess what is being done and how we can help with the immediate situation. I'm sure there will also be advocacy for the broader issues involved."

"We are called to care for the least of these and called to greet and care for the immigrant as well," Clark said. "It's the responsibility of the faith community and the UCC to meet the needs of these strangers who have come into our midst, and to help communities understand how we can have a loving response to those who are seeking our help."
As Auden said, may we, like them, show an affirming flame.

Tuesday, July 08, 2014

FOOD FIGHT!!!!!


This is sure to provoke much flinging of poo:

If your idea of God is not one that most theistic traditions would recognize, you’re not talking about God (at most, the New Atheists’ arguments are relevant to the low-hanging god of fundamentalism and deism). But even more damning is that such atheists appear ignorant of atheism as well. 
Not to mention the review uses words like "ontic" and "ontology," which I'm not even sure Richard Dawkins knows how to use correctly (much less Pharyngula, or the "atheists" hanging out at Salon who get in a lather if you call them "neo-Atheists."  Like they'd know what a real atheist, like Bertrand Russell, was.)

And this, I thought, was the "money shot:"

What Spencer recounts is the true history of atheism, which
had only a limited amount to do with reason and even less with science. The creation myth in which a few brave souls forged weapons made of a previously unknown material, to which the religious were relentlessly opposed, is an invention of the later nineteenth century, albeit one with ongoing popular appeal. In reality … modern atheism was primarily a political and social cause, its development in Europe having rather more to do with the (ab)use of theologically legitimized political authority than it does with developments in science or philosophy.
As I've said before (I'm sure), the arguments always (even in theological circles) have more to do with power than with theology, or, more broadly, religion.  And when you don't even know what religion or theology are, how can you be arguing about anything else but power?

Well, and just to enjoy the clarity of thought in this review:

To paraphrase the Scottish philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre, our moral vocabulary has lost the contexts from which its significance derived, and no amount of Dawkins-style hand-waving about altruistic genes will make the problem go away. (Indeed, the ridiculous belief that our genes determine everything about human behavior and culture is a symptom of this very problem.) 
Or this quote from John Gray:

Driven to the margins of a culture in which science claims authority over all of human knowledge, [religious believers] have had to cultivate a capacity for doubt. In contrast, secular believers—held fast by the conventional wisdom of the time—are in the grip of unexamined dogmas.
I don't quite agree with the predicate, but I'll accept it arguendo for the sake of the conclusion.

I will say no more except that it is a refreshingly intelligent discussion, if brief and centered on a book I don't plan to read (life's too short), for the internet.  And I'll stay away from the 1.6K (as I write) comments there, especially if the top comment (excerpted in a side bar) is any indication ("The author commits the same fallacy as Pascal--conflating 'God' and 'religion' with his particular brand of Christianity."  That isn't, by the way, the problem with Pascal's wager.)   It's a comment that perfectly reflects the last words of the review:  “Everyone is talking past each other and no one seems to be elevating the conversation to where it could and should be.”

Pascal's wager?  Seriously?  Feh!

Even the clowns in the comments at Religion Dispatches should take heed.*

*I like RD, but they draw their share of ignorance, too.

Christmas in July--for lawyers

Mmmmm....cooked goose!

I don't mean to make a fetish of the "corporate veil" problem that I think Burwell sets up, but I've noted more and more references to that problem lately.

NTodd caught one, at dKos:

Because corporations exist in order to put up a barrier between a business and its owners, that means that the religious liberty of the owners cannot be violated by anything the corporation is compelled, by law, to do. Business owners want to benefit from the doctrine of corporate separateness when creditors want their money, and start acting like Paulie from "Goodfellas" (i.e., "$@*% you, pay me!"). When that happens, the owners want to be able to throw up their hands and say, "Sorry, that's not me, that's the business." Piercing that corporate veil is supposed to be difficult. But all of a sudden, the Roberts Five is agreeing with business owners who want to turn around and say—when it comes to their interpretation of religion—that the business  the owners. They can't have it both ways.
I'm not a legal genius or a constitutional scholar, and I'm certainly not the only person to make this argument, as you can see above. But it is such a Captain Obvious point that the only explanation that fits is that Roberts Five simply doesn't care. I used the word farce. I stand by it.
And I found another this morning, which indicates corporate lawyers are aware of the risk, too:

Hobby Lobby and Conestoga each asserts that the religious values of its present controlling shareholders should pass through to the corporation itself. This Court should reject any such “values pass-through” concept. To do otherwise would run contrary to established principles of corporate law.

The essence of a corporation is its “separateness” from its shareholders. It is a distinct legal entity, with its own rights and obligations, different from the rights and obligations of its shareholders. This Court has repeatedly recognized this separateness.
The outline of the argument in that brief is telling.  Sections include:

B)  The Corporation's separate existence protects its shareholders from liability for corporate debts, thereby investment, innovation, and job creation

C)  The Corporation's separate existence permits a business to operate notwithstanding the death of disability of its founders or changes in share ownership, thereby promoting stability and predictability in business operations

True, these read like GOP talking points, but they are also valid issues in corporate law.  My favorite, however, points to the very uncertain legal future created by Burwell, a future the Court can't hope to control:

D)  The separation between a corporation and its shareholders is a principle not only of corporate law, but also of agency law and of criminal law.

The law is a web; touch one strand, and you tremble them all.

It is, however, the penultimate section that sums up  the argument of this brief, and points to the problem the Court created:

E)  This Court should not allow Hobby Lobby and Conestoga to selectively disregard the corporate veil that separates them from their shareholders. 

The Court might argue that it precisely did allow a narrow, selective reverse piercing of the corporate veil to allow Hobby Lobby to have the religious beliefs of its owners; but as the brief clearly points out, sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

So now the question is:  in the case of the closely held corporation, is that corporate goose cooked?

Friday, July 04, 2014

"I do not think that word means what you think it means."

Freedom's just another word for fireworks on the 4th!
 As long as no one has a religious objection....

I saw this, but didn't have a link to the opinion.  Now, via NTodd, I do:

RFRA requires Wheaton to show that the accommodation process “substantially burden[s] [its] exercise of religion.” “Congress no doubt meant the modifier ‘substantially’ to carry weight…”

[...]

Let me be absolutely clear: I do not doubt that Wheaton genuinely believes that signing the self-certification form is contrary to its religious beliefs. But thinking one’s religious beliefs are substantially burdened—no matter how sincere or genuine that belief may be—does not make it so.
An analogy used by the Seventh Circuit may help to explain why Wheaton’s complicity theory cannot be legally sound:
“Suppose it is wartime, there is a draft, and a Quaker is called up. Many Quakers are pacifists, and their pacifism is a tenet of their religion. Suppose the Quaker who’s been called up tells the selective service system that he’s a conscientious objector. The selective service officer to whom he makes this pitch accepts the sincerity of his refusal to bear arms and excuses him. But as the Quaker leaves the selective service office, he’s told: ‘you know this means we’ll have to draft someone in place of you’—and the Quaker replies indignantly that if the government does that, it will be violating his religious beliefs. Because his religion teaches that no one should bear arms, drafting another person in his place would make him responsible for the military activities of his replacement, and by doing so would substantially burden his own sincere religious beliefs. Would this mean that by exempting him the government had forced him to ‘trigger’ the drafting of a replacement who was not a conscientious objector, and that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act would require a draft exemption for both the Quaker and his non‐Quaker replacement?”

Here, similarly, the filing of the self-certification form merely indicates to the third-party administrator that a religious nonprofit has chosen to invoke the religious accommodation. If a religious nonprofit chooses not to pay for contraceptive services, it is true that someone else may have a legal obligation to pay for them, just as someone may have to go to war in place of the conscientious objector. But the obligation to provide contraceptive services, like the obligation to serve in the Armed Forces, arises not from the filing of the form but from the underlying law and regulations.It may be that what troubles Wheaton is that it must participate in any process the end result of which might be the provision of contraceptives to its employees. But that is far from a substantial burden on its free exercise of religion.
"Substantial burden" is the test established by the Court for these cases in 1962, reaffirmed in 1972, and codified by RFRA.  But now, with Burwell, cases under RFRA need meet only an alleged burden, to be a substantial burden.

Which means the Court has just elevated RFRA above even the 1st Amendment.

This is a worse outcome than I had realized.   Effectively, any claim of mere inconvenience of religious beliefs, a claim which must be taken at face value by the court, under RFRA now means thecorporation making the claim is absolved of all responsibilities under the law complained of.  I am sympathetic to rick's arguments in comments below that some balance is needed; but I don't think Burwell is that balance, at all.

BTW:  Happy Birthday to my grate gud frend, rick!

Thursday, July 03, 2014

"....makes the world go around...."

Last in a series, I promise; at this point I'm just cleaning off the desk, so to speak.

I'm still ruminating on this, but it strikes me that the issue here (in Burwell) is the question of agency*:  at what point is my money no longer "my money," and the use of it no longer under my control, or even my responsibility?

An employer provides insurance as an employment benefit, which means it is no different than the agreed upon salary the employee accepts to do the job.  By offering insurance, the employer agrees to pay for that insurance as a part of the employee's compensation, just as the employer agrees to pay a wage on a set schedule.  Indeed, in Texas, if an employer does not pay on the agreed schedule that employer is in violation of state law.  The property interest of the employee in at least their wages is protected by law.  And, of course, the use of those wages by the employee (provided the use is legal) is left entirely to the employee.

The government says that the insurance policy so provided cannot be worthless, that it must make certain basic provisions.  It does not dictate the size of the deductible, for example, but it does dictate what will be covered so all have basic medical care available to them.  Of course, given the expense of healthcare it could legitimately be a moral issue as to whether an insurance deductible is fair, or not (because a high deductible can still effectively exclude you from some healthcare.  I just bought some relatively inexpensive drugs which, were it not for the program at my pharmacy reducing the cost to $20.00, would have cost me $140.00.  I have a deductible I never reach because aside from two minor chronic health issues controlled by generic drugs, I don't spend enough on healthcare in any one year.  If not for that pharmacy program, I might find my healthcare far more expensive, and if I were a bit poorer....)

Now comes Hobby Lobby, which objects that the insurance policy it buys means the insurance company must provide coverage for contraceptive care to the insured.  The money leaves Hobby Lobby, goes to the insurance company, and MAY be used to buy contraceptives (it doesn't have to be, of course), and Hobby Lobby says that's a violation of its religious feelings.

Okay, the money leaves the employers hands and goes directly to the employee, who uses it to buy alcohol, which may also be a violation of the employer's religious feelings.  Or, more to the point, the employee MAY buy alcohol with that money.  In either case we tell the employer:  tough.  It's no longer your money.

Why is it still the employer's money when it gets to the insurance company?**

*Not that the majority opinion wanted to address that issue in any way, shape, or form.  They clearly and tacitly left all questions of agency in the hands of the corporate owners, and allowed for no autonomy of the employees, who can make their own decisions about whether or not to use contraceptives.  The Court might as well have complained that Hobby Lobby exists in a world where contraceptives are available and where employees might purchase such things with the money Hobby Lobby "gives" them (because compensation belongs to the employer even after it is earned, in the logic of the majority opinion).

**The answer is:  because this case is not about contraceptives or religious beliefs, or even about money.  It is about opposition to the ACA.  If there is a moral issue with contraceptives, there isn't a valid legal one:

Today's opinion reflects not a principled judgment about the meaning of RFRA but the Republican majority's policy opposition to the ACA, and its failure to take the rights and interests of the women employees affected by its decision seriously. That these justices may not apply the same logic when the mandate is for something other than contraception isn't much of a defense of their holding.  


And that it isn't about "religious beliefs" is clear from the special privilege religious beliefs held by the owners of closely-held corporations suddenly get at law, a privilege offered to no other group in America:


I agree that on the question of whether there is any conflict between religious practice and a statute, the courts should be deferential to an individual’s characterization of their beliefs. The legal standard, however, is not whether there is “any” conflict. It’s whether there is a substantial conflict. Courts do not have to be deferential on this question, and indeed since the finding of a substantial burden triggers the rare use of heightened scrutiny they can’t be deferential.  And for the reasons Edwards explains, this is pretty much the definition of a de minimis burden: the Gilardis are not required to use contraception, required to promote the use of contraception, or denied the right to publicly oppose the use of contraception. Being required to offer insurance plans that cover contraception may constitute a burden, but it’s not the “substantial” one Sherbert requires. In Sherbert and Yoder, there was a clear, direct burden involved, not an incidental one.

The idea that an irrefutable bare assertion of conflict with religious belief, no matter how trivial, is sufficient to make any state action subject to strict scrutiny is absurd. It’s an obviously unworkable standard, it’s not what the Court said in Sherbert, and it’s not the policy enacted by Congress, which also requires a “substantial” burden. The backdoor attempt to subject all regulations to strict scrutiny does, however, show what’s going on here: this case is about opposition to the ACA, not religious freedom.