So, this morning, I read this, got this far:
One reason is that the Bible actually gives two different sets of Ten Commandments, and they don’t match. In Exodus 20, Moses comes down from Mount Sinai with a set of stone tablets. (This is the most popular version.) Then he gets mad and smashes them and has to go back up and get another set. And God says, “Hew thee two tables of stone like unto the first: and I will write upon these tables the words that were in the first tables, which thou brakest.” (Exodus 34:1). But then, apparently, God can’t resist tweaking them a little. Ok, a lot.
and thought: "Hey, wait a minute," and pulled a Bible off my shelf. Quicker than Google, I was browsing Exodus. My suspicions confirmed (and against my better judgment) I left a comment:
Um, if you're gonna write about it, you might want to read Exodus, rather than watch the Charlton Heston movie.
The so-called Decalogue is delivered in Exodus 20: 1-17. The catalogue of laws is interrupted by the terror of the people at the theophany (basically a huge thunderstorm) taking place atop Sinai. The people speak to Moses (which is weird, isn't he on the mountain?), and then God goes back to delivering laws, of which the Decalogue is only the first ten. The laws go on until Exodus 23:19, and then there's a longer passage about a ritual (I won't even bother with what it's for). It's in Exodus 32:19 that Moses destroys the tablets with ALL the law (not just the first 10; again, that's DeMille, not Exodus), and so gets a new set starting in Exodus 34.
And I suspect a bit of historical scholarship would expose the importance of the Decalogue to Christians as of recent, Protestant vintage, not something going back to the 1st century, as I don't recall any mention of it in the book of Acts or the letters of Paul.
Which would kind of shift the whole "Christians get it all wrong" thesis of this article to "some Christians of more recent vintage," and then maybe we could say which ones, and why. Or is a gross generalization that doesn't really account for anything except your preferred conclusion, based largely on ignorance, not insight, for only one acceptable outcome?
@Adventus ...or we can conclude the bible is a veritable Rorschach test, with each reader coming to his or her own conclusions.
Frankly, your analysis of the bible seems as misguided as those of the writer of this piece.
@Adventus Whatever. The entire thing is irrelevant fiction. Parsing irrelevant fictions is a waste of time and energy that could be better spent learning how to be a decent human being.
@Aunt Messy @Adventus Thank you, Aunt Messy! I have never understood why the heck people "religiously" attend "Bible Study" classses - for what? It is a lengthy (some might say tedious), frequently violent, misogynist, series of parables and stories about some vengeful deity who advocates all sorts of mayhem for misbehavior and "forgetting him". Whatever happened to "live and let live"? How about the famous Rodney King jeremiad: "Can't we all just get along?"
I really don't get it. My only comment was on the accuracy of the reporting of what Exodus said; not on the accuracy of Exodus as history of events, nor the analysis in the article (which is pretty piss poor, and as I mentioned in passing, assumes a lot about the history of Christianity which I'm not sure is valid.).
The reigning assumption is that all Christians are fundamentalists, and have been since Paul died (I as often see Paul blamed for messing up Christianity as I see the "Old Testament" labelled a book full of a vengeful and wrathful God, and nothing like Jesus; which is so illiterate it's downright sad). Point out that "the Fundamentals" were written in the early 20th century, and the monkeys hoot and fling poo at you. (I know, I know, it's a tiresome metaphor by now, but read those comments again and tell me if you don't think "Welcome to the Monkey House" is a phrase that springs to mind).
I know better than to bother; and I report on it to clear it out of my mind. Something even odder happened to me today, which merits its own post. Just consider these diary entries on what a long, strange trip it's been.






