Oliver Willis:
If the people we hired to fight republicans are bad at the job it’s our duty to say so
emptywheel replies:
Oliver keeps outsourcing his agency.
Not
His
Job
It's pundits like this that explain why Dems will never match right wing online pushback.
"Online pushback” is a sign of being terminally online, just like Beltway gossip (e.g., “Trump is mad at Elmo” or “Jake Tapper wrote a book”) is terminally out of touch with America. Both imagine an America (or a Texas, a California, a take-your-pick,) that exists only in the established narrative, and every two years they fit the last election into that narrative; whatever it takes.
But that’s not to say ew is wrong.
Oliver replies to ew:Lol apparently it’s my job to fight the Republican Party instead of it being the job of Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, Hakeem Jeffries, Barack Obama and others. My job is to advocate for progress in America. That means fighting the right and calling out their Democratic Party enablers.
ew...Oops!!!
That "instead of" is the tell.
Dude. You're not just a citizen but you're a pundit.
Start acting like one instead of outsourcing all your agency to other people.
EVEN MERE CITIZENS are doing more than you are.
...
replies to Oliver:Right wingers manage to serve as assignment editors for vast swaths of journalism.
And left wingers? Whine and demand only elected politicians do the hard work.
Both sides here seem to think the re-election of Trump is a sign of cosmic, if not apocalyptic, doom looming on the horizon; rather than mere unfortunate circumstances. In hindsight Biden really should have followed LBJ’s example and bowed out of the race for another term altogether. LBJ didn’t get the credit he deserved for improving America; and until Biden’s administration, I thought that was due to Vietnam. But a lot of what LBJ did created the country we accept as a given, now. It took a long time for PBS and Medicare/Medicaid and fair housing and civil rights and, basically, our modern world, to become “normal” and “given.” The same country Trump is trying to disassemble, which is why so many voters have buyer’s remorse. What LBJ and Biden did wasn’t/won’t be apparent for years; and as Nixon followed LBJ (voters rejected HHH, his VP, too), Trump followed Biden. And when Nixon couldn’t buffalo North Vietnam and end the war quickly, he struck the deal that ended with the helicopters leaving people behind in ‘75 (Ford’s term, as it turned out), and kept the war going just so that didn’t happen until he was re-elected.
In some ways, Trump is just a more useless Nixon. Except “Trump” doesn’t rhyme with “Nixon.”
The Democratic Party was fractious and broken in ‘68, amid the deaths of MLK and RFK, and Daley’s police riot in Chicago, and “Clean Gene” trying to rally a youth vote that couldn’t yet vote. It got worse in ‘72 (McGovern carried Massachusetts; and no other state). Carter lasted one term; Clinton had two. Obama defeated Hillary; and Biden defeated Trump, and convinced himself he alone was the Trump killer.
And now Democrats are winning every special election being held; but Dems are in disarray, because they don’t listen to people with BlueSky or Twitter accounts. Very Serious People who think Pundits are the unacknowledged legislators of the world.
And if there is a simple summation, it’s this: that “idea” is how we got MAGA.
The country doesn’t need an anti-Trump. It doesn’t need yet another attempted takeover of the Democratic Party (‘68; ‘72; ‘88; 204-2008. Been there, done that; bought ALL the t-shirts.). Candidates win elections. Not Big Ideas. Not Big Concepts. Candidates. The absolutely ONLY thing Trump did right in 2024 was deny all knowledge of PROJECT 2025. It’s the only thing that would have stopped him. Otherwise he didn’t really campaign, and voters didn’t really pay attention to the ineptitude of his campaign. They just refused to vote for the Black woman, despite how qualified she was. Kamala Harris could never overcome being black and female. Maybe she could after another 4 years of Trump. (I’m pretty sure that’s how Obama won, TBH.)
We’ll see if she even gets the chance.