Monday, June 21, 2021

Does Time Actually Move “Forward”?

Before we get to that, a nice summary statement of just what "critical race theory" is, and how it isn't "racism."

The [Ku Klux] Klan worked to put its racist beliefs into action through Jim Crow laws in the South and immigration restrictions for the nation as a whole; critical race theorists have devoted themselves to identifying the remainders of that racism in the law and rooting it out.

And, most obviously, the KKK was a terrorist organization responsible for decades of white supremacist violence that included thousands of murders, mutilations and bombings of African Americans and other minorities. The law school professors behind critical race theory are not.
What brought that explanation on?  Why, the Junior Senator from Texas, of course, who apparently has nothing better to do with his government-funded time:

Despite the vast differences between the Klan and critical race theorists, Cruz twisted himself into knots insisting they were the same by grossly misrepresenting the scholarly field. "Critical race theory says every white person is a racist," the senator asserted. "Critical race theory says America's fundamentally racist and irredeemably racist. Critical race theory seeks to turn us against each other and if someone has a different color skin, seeks to make us hate that person."
To say I've heard this shit before would be an understatement.  I grew up ON this shit.  I learned, early on, that racists were knuckle-draggers who hated "ni**ers" and used that ugly word freely.  In fact, the best way to determine who was a racist was the people who used that word.  Then there were those who were "just" "prejudiced."  As in, "I got nothing against 'em, I just don't want my kid goin' to school with 'em."  Then there were the true liberals, exemplified by Katherine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy as a movie couple who find out their daughter wants to marry one; which was, among non-liberals, an acceptable form of not being racist or prejudiced.  I mean, after all, miscegenation was illegal!  (It wasn't by 1968, but anyway....).

I've limned this problem before: it's all racism.  It's just that some of the racism is acceptable, and some of it isn't.  It still isn't.  Which is what's causing Cruz to squeal like a stuck pig.  Even though he's a racist.  I have no trouble saying that.  I'm a racist, too.  Not because I hated non-whites (whatever that means), but because I've been taught the fictional category of "race" until I can't not think in racial terms.  I am tainted with America's original sin, in just the sense Augustine meant the more Christian term:  I was born into it, and I can't escape it now.

And I equally grew up with the ideas Cruz is just parroting here; there's nothing original in what he says.  He picked it up as a kid, too.  He just didn't have the good sense to put it down again.  With or without critical race theory, I'll say it:  every white person in America is a racist.  Everyone who thinks in terms of race, is a racist.  It has nothing to do with power or lack thereof; if we identify people by skin color or genetics or appearance ("racial characteristics"), we're engaging in racism.  It's that pernicious.  Own it, or you can't do anything about it.

Jesus said love your neighbor; and to be first of all, you must be last and servant of all.  Jesus also said it was easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to get into heaven; and that despite his Father's house having many mansions, at the end you'll be judged on who you showed kindness to, because in serving them, you served God directly.  There's as much harsh as there is kind in Christ's teachings, as much seemingly exclusionary as there is inclusive.  "Lord, when did we see you?" is the plaintive cry of the lost who realize it's too late now.  Recognize that, Matthew means; or you'll wish you had.

Recognize the original American sin of racism; or we'll never do anything about it.

Rather than believing America is “irredeemably racist,” critical race theorists have stated that their reckoning with the submerged role of racism in America is a path to redeem the nation and fulfill the promises of emancipation and the 13th, 14th and 15th Amendments. Critical race theorists also do not seek to turn Americans against each other, but rather to help them understand the actual history of the nation they share as citizens.

While Cruz’s claim that critical race theorists are “every bit as racist” as Klansmen is laughable, it notably fits into a larger historical pattern in which white southerners asserted that the critics of white supremacy were just as bad — or worse — than the defenders of white supremacy.

Exactly.  This is an old, old song.  Cruz is not an original; Cruz is a mouthpiece.  Then again, so is this guy:

 "Thank you for sharing what you really have in your heart," Cash wrote. "You hate white men and white little boys and Christians. I hope I didn't miss anything. My family has crossed cultural lines for many years. Including Hispanic, Black and family members from Malta. And I must say of all the conversations we have had knowone (sic) has ever demonstrated the amount of hate that I see in this email. I will pray that you look at people as individuals rather than by race and look at the content of their character vs what has happened before. Focus on all the great accomplishments we have had in race relations in our Country."

That is a school board member, writing to a parent of children in those schools. The defensiveness is part of the argument; as it is for Cruz.  It's an attempt to negate argument, to refuse to consider alternatives, to demonize the other so no conversation is necessary, or even possible.

I grew up with this shit.  Time is not even a flat circle.  Time is just a smear; of tar, or molasses, I still haven't decided.  I know better than to say this shit is from everlasting to everlasting; but it sure does feel that way sometimes.

3 comments:

  1. Another variation on the theme that I grew up with is "they're one of the good ones". It usually comes up in, "how can I be racist, I have a _______ friend". Maybe a co-worker, more likely you knew someone in high school that was in a few classes or on your sports team. They were ok because "they were one of the good ones". As for the rest, all the racist attitudes and language applies. Just because you have a friend or two of color doesn't mean you aren't racist if that is how you think of them.

    I hold out more hope for my kids, they seem to be moving in the right direction. I am too old, steeped in our racist culture and taught to think of people by color and category. I didn't learn it at home, but I know it well enough. It pops up in the reaction before the brain kicks in and forces me to actually think about what I just did. I am still trying to track down the actual legislation so I can read the language, but New Hampshire (Live Free or Die, but don't talk about race!) will pass a law banning it. The entire two year budget would have to be vetoed at this point to kill it and that won't be happening. The language has been amended a number of times. At one point you couldn't teach that America isn't a meritocracy (the rich have earned and deserve every penny they have!).

    We are going backwards.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Or we have one foot nailed to the floor. And we nailed it there.

      Although one step forward, two steps back, seems to describe it pretty well, too.

      Delete
  2. In the category of backwards. We are mid-move, everything we own is in the moving truck, house sold and hopefully we close on the new one Monday. Lots of emotions as we say our final goodbyes to schools, friends and more.

    The neighbors sold their house a few weeks before ours. Two days before the closing, the buyers pulled out. They wrote a letter explaining their change of mind. Their reason? There weren't enough white people in our neighborhood. (Point of fact, our neighborhood is large majority white. In the 23 years since we first moved to this neighborhood, it has become more multi-racial. Within a few houses the buyers would have had to live with a mixed race family, a south asian family, and several mixed white and south asian families.
    The neighborhood is essentially all professionals, doctors, lawyers, teachers, professors and managers). Five years ago I don't think anyone would have dared write that letter. In our current environment, the buyers felt that was okay to put down on paper. (Why the buyer's agent or attorney would have delivered such a letter is beyond me.) A segment of our country has not only nailed their feet to the floor, but is proud of the accomplishment.

    ReplyDelete