Sunday, December 18, 2016

Fourth Sunday of Advent 2016: "When you are old and grey and full of sleep"

Isaiah 7:10-16
7:10 Again the LORD spoke to Ahaz, saying,

7:11 Ask a sign of the LORD your God; let it be deep as Sheol or high as heaven.

7:12 But Ahaz said, I will not ask, and I will not put the LORD to the test.

7:13 Then Isaiah said: "Hear then, O house of David! Is it too little for you to weary mortals, that you weary my God also?

7:14 Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign. Look, the young woman is with child and shall bear a son, and shall name him Immanuel.

7:15 He shall eat curds and honey by the time he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good.

7:16 For before the child knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good, the land before whose two kings you are in dread will be deserted.

Psalm 80:1-7, 17-19
80:1 Give ear, O Shepherd of Israel, you who lead Joseph like a flock! You who are enthroned upon the cherubim, shine forth

80:2 before Ephraim and Benjamin and Manasseh. Stir up your might, and come to save us!

80:3 Restore us, O God; let your face shine, that we may be saved.

80:4 O LORD God of hosts, how long will you be angry with your people's prayers?

80:5 You have fed them with the bread of tears, and given them tears to drink in full measure.

80:6 You make us the scorn of our neighbors; our enemies laugh among themselves.

80:7 Restore us, O God of hosts; let your face shine, that we may be saved.

80:17 But let your hand be upon the one at your right hand, the one whom you made strong for yourself.

80:18 Then we will never turn back from you; give us life, and we will call on your name.

80:19 Restore us, O LORD God of hosts; let your face shine, that we may be saved.

Romans 1:1-7
1:1 Paul, a servant of Jesus Christ, called to be an apostle, set apart for the gospel of God,

1:2 which he promised beforehand through his prophets in the holy scriptures,

1:3 the gospel concerning his Son, who was descended from David according to the flesh

1:4 and was declared to be Son of God with power according to the spirit of holiness by resurrection from the dead, Jesus Christ our Lord,

1:5 through whom we have received grace and apostleship to bring about the obedience of faith among all the Gentiles for the sake of his name,

1:6 including yourselves who are called to belong to Jesus Christ,

1:7 To all God's beloved in Rome, who are called to be saints: Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.

Matthew 1:18-25
1:18 Now the birth of Jesus the Messiah took place in this way. When his mother Mary had been engaged to Joseph, but before they lived together, she was found to be with child from the Holy Spirit.

1:19 Her husband Joseph, being a righteous man and unwilling to expose her to public disgrace, planned to dismiss her quietly.

1:20 But just when he had resolved to do this, an angel of the Lord appeared to him in a dream and said, "Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife, for the child conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit.

1:21 She will bear a son, and you are to name him Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins."

1:22 All this took place to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet:

1:23 "Look, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and they shall name him Emmanuel," which means, "God is with us."

1:24 When Joseph awoke from sleep, he did as the angel of the Lord commanded him; he took her as his wife,

1:25 but had no marital relations with her until she had borne a son; and he named him Jesus.

I've thought more and more lately, as I enter "old age," as I care for my elderly parents and see my future in their lives, what Joseph would have appreciate the words of his son at the end of John's Gospel:  "...when you have grown old, you'll stretch out your arms, and someone else will get you ready and take you where you don't want to go."  Because it's pretty clear from Matthew's account that the angel is telling Joseph to go somewhere he doesn't want to go.

Joseph here is Abraham.  Mary is pregnant, and that means someone else has been with her.  But the angel of the Lord tells Joseph a story, and Joseph accepts it without question.  He is Abraham, being told by God to leave his people and go where God will lead him, and with no more assurance than that, Abraham goes.  With no more reason to believe than that, Abraham believes.  Joseph is Abraham.  Israel's history is repeating itself.  Maybe Abraham didn't want to go there; but he did.  Maybe Joseph doesn't want to do this; but he does.  Your betrothed is pregnant, but it's okay, it's not the child of another man, but of God?  Sure, why not?

And notice it is Matthew who changes "young woman" to "virgin."  There are endless discussions about why that happened, ranging from historical accuracy to an unfortunate misquote, maybe even a poor transition from Hebrew to Greek.  No matter; it suits Matthew's story that Jesus of Nazareth was not merely human; it suits Matthew's claim that Jesus came directly from God.  And it keeps Joseph in charge, even though Joseph is only the father legally.

But it isn't at all clear this is where Joseph wants to go.

When Joseph was an old man, an old man was he
He married Virgin Mary, the Queen of Galilee
He married Virgin Mary, the Queen of Galilee

But was Joseph an old man?  Tradition says so, but again, it doesn't matter.  We have him fixed in our minds that way; better to leave him there.  Did he object to his wife's pregnancy?  Matthew implies a mild objection, but one aimed at protecting Mary.  Tradition, again, embellishes:

Then Joseph flew in anger, in anger flew he
Let the father of the baby gather cherries for thee!
Let the father of the baby gather cherries for thee!

Isaiah writes before the Exile that is coming; the Psalmist writes from that Exile; they both await a very real, very physical salvation from the Lord.  Matthew writes in the aftermath of that exile and the failure of Israel to continue as a sovereign nation.  If he uses the words of Isaiah for his own purposes, who can blame him?  If we add details to the bare bones of his nativity story, who can blame us?  We need to understand this.  We need to make these people, people we recognize.  "The Cherry Tree Carol" does that with a miracle, an act of power (dounamis in the Greek, the word used for "miracle" in Matthew, Mark, and Luke) which is also a semeia, a sign (John's "miracle").  What do we do to make this story human, in our terms?

We see Joseph trying to be a good man, and to protect Mary if he can.  We see Joseph accept the word of a dream that he can adopt the son as his own; and that will protect Mary, too.  We see Joseph name the child, which makes the child his own.  Already we see they were "each one quite odd:  a mensch, a virgin, and a god."

And he does what he is asked, because he accepts the word of God.

There is much we can learn about faith from Joseph.  We only know that, like Abraham, he accepts what he is told.  We never learn why.  The story doesn't penetrate to his psyche, to his inner dialogue. He doesn't even question the angel, or declare himself a servant of the Lord.  He just does as he is told.  But just as Mary does before Gabriel, Joseph accepts.  His actions speak for him.

There are things we consider commands in the scripture; the angel's word to Joseph is not one of them, anymore than God's word to Abraham to leave his land and people and go to where God will lead, is a command.  If Abraham were commanded rather than directed, if he acted in response to an imperative rather than chose to act in faith, how would Abraham be an example to us?  Where would his trust, his faith, be?  If Joseph had no choice but to follow the angel's words, what credit would that be to him?  We have commands in Christianity; this time of year, especially, we even talk about them:

WHAT keeps you from giving now? Isn't the poor person there? Aren't your own warehouses full? Isn't the reward promised? The command is clear: the hungry person is dying now, the naked person is freezing now, the person in debt is beaten now-and you want to wait until tomorrow? "I'm not doing any harm," you say. "I just want to keep what I own, that's all." You own! You are like someone who sits down in a theater and keeps everyone else away, saying that what is there for everyone's use is your own. . . . If everyone took only what they needed and gave the rest to those in need, there would be no such thing as rich and poor. After all, didn't you come into life naked, and won't you return naked to the earth?

The bread in your cupboard belongs to the hungry person; the coat hanging unused in your closet belongs to the person who needs it; the shoes rotting in your closet belong to the person with no shoes; the money which you put in the bank belongs to the poor. You do wrong to everyone you could help, but fail to help.

--Basil, 4th century
We need to make the concerns of the hungry, the naked, the prisoner, into commands; and even then we can't seem to follow them.  Perhaps we need to learn to let someone else get us ready, and let someone else take us where we do not want to go.  Perhaps, for at least the rest of Advent and Christmastide, we should ask ourselves:  What would Joseph do?

Saturday, December 17, 2016

Peace on earth.....?

And then there's this:

“It is understood that China and the United States are using military channels to appropriately handle this issue,” China’s Foreign Ministry said in a brief statement sent to Reuters, without elaborating.

The Global Times, published by the ruling Communist Party’s official People’s Daily, said a Chinese naval vessel had discovered “unidentified equipment” and checked it to prevent any navigational safety issues. It cited an unidentified Chinese source.

“This person said China has already received a claim request for the equipment from the U.S. side. Relevant parties from both sides have maintained smooth communication channels and believe this issue will be smoothly resolved,” the paper said.

China’s Defence Ministry has yet to comment publicly on the issue.

“The UUV was lawfully conducting a military survey in the waters of the South China Sea,” a U.S. official said, speaking on condition of anonymity. “It’s a sovereign immune vessel, clearly marked in English not to be removed from the water - that it was U.S. property,” the official said.

The Pentagon confirmed the incident at a news briefing on Friday, and said the drone used commercially available technology and sold for about $150,000.

Still, the Pentagon viewed China’s seizure seriously since it had effectively taken U.S. military property.

“It is ours, and it is clearly marked as ours and we would like it back. And we would like this not to happen again,” Pentagon spokesman Jeff Davis said.
So:  does somebody take this idiot's Twitter account away on January 20th?  Or do we let him tweet us into war?

Friday, December 16, 2016

This is where we are....


Because the point Trump is making is that e-mails were released, and it's okay to read other people's e-mails.

There is still enough of an expectation of privacy in "snail mail" that if Wikileaks, or any other actor, were to release thousands of scanned letters onto the world wide web, I suspect there would be a scandal that personal mail was being spread out for the world to see.  The content might be alluring, but the idea of stealing people's mail, or just publishing it without their permission (the permission of both sender and receiver, IOW), would still be scandalous.

There are family members who tightly control the private letters of public figures when the latter are dead, and no one would expect a "hacker" to get digital copies of those letters and publish them with no repercussions for doing so.

Or imagine tapping the phones of the DNC, and releasing transcripts of all the phone conversations.  Would that be okay?  But e-mail is different.  When e-mails are released, we all congratulate the leaker (or at least look the other way).  We don't think, for a moment, about where that information came from, how it was acquired, whether it should be in the public domain.

Well, some of us do; but apparently the PEOTUS doesn't.  The "same cyberattack" was okay, because we learned that Donna Brazile cheated on behalf of Hillary.  See, no crime here!  Look at what was revealed!

Is it only a matter of time before stealing mail and tapping phones will be as acceptable?

Adding:  Already it's a meme!  What a coincidence!

A Republican congressman from New York was unfazed by reports that Russian-backed hackers sought to influence the election outcome and argued that emails stolen from the Democratic National Committee, Hillary Clinton campaign chair John Podesta and others were useful to voters because they revealed Democrats' “lies and deceit.”

A Modest electoral proposal


There is a lot of arguing going on about the Electoral College but, as far as I know, little judicial history on the subject (that is, no case law interpreting the words of the Constitution).  So here is what the Constitution says about it:

Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.
The Congress may determine the Time of choosing the Electors, and the Day on which they shall give their Votes; which Day shall be the same throughout the United States.
Twelfth Amendment
The Electors shall meet in their respective states, and vote by ballot for President and Vice-President, one of whom, at least, shall not be an inhabitant of the same state with themselves; they shall name in their ballots the person voted for as President, and in distinct ballots the person voted for as Vice-President, and they shall make distinct lists of all persons voted for as President, and of all persons voted for as Vice-President, and of the number of votes for each, which lists they shall sign and certify, and transmit sealed to the seat of the government of the United States, directed to the President of the Senate;

And here is the beginning of Hamilton's argument for the electoral college:

THE mode of appointment of the Chief Magistrate of the United States is almost the only part of the system, of any consequence, which has escaped without severe censure, or which has received the slightest mark of approbation from its opponents. The most plausible of these, who has appeared in print, has even deigned to admit that the election of the President is pretty well guarded.1 I venture somewhat further, and hesitate not to affirm, that if the manner of it be not perfect, it is at least excellent. It unites in an eminent degree all the advantages, the union of which was to be wished for.

It was desirable that the sense of the people should operate in the choice of the person to whom so important a trust was to be confided. This end will be answered by committing the right of making it, not to any preestablished body, but to men chosen by the people for the special purpose, and at the particular conjuncture.

It was equally desirable, that the immediate election should be made by men most capable of analyzing the qualities adapted to the station, and acting under circumstances favorable to deliberation, and to a judicious combination of all the reasons and inducements which were proper to govern their choice. A small number of persons, selected by their fellow-citizens from the general mass, will be most likely to possess the information and discernment requisite to such complicated investigations.
I would note, first, that arguments that the states cannot direct the votes of electors is on dubious ground based on the language in Article 2, because the appointment of electors was left to the States, through their legislatures.

Today, state laws are apparently uniform on the manner in which electors are chosen, if not in the laws that require them to vote as the electorate directed and their pledge dictates.  This is the best information I have on the subject, and I will simply quote it:

There is no Constitutional provision or Federal law that requires Electors to vote according to the results of the popular vote in their states. Some states, however, require Electors to cast their votes according to the popular vote. These pledges fall into two categories—Electors bound by state law and those bound by pledges to political parties.

The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the Constitution does not require that Electors be completely free to act as they choose and therefore, political parties may extract pledges from electors to vote for the parties' nominees. Some state laws provide that so-called "faithless Electors" may be subject to fines or may be disqualified for casting an invalid vote and be replaced by a substitute elector. The Supreme Court has not specifically ruled on the question of whether pledges and penalties for failure to vote as pledged may be enforced under the Constitution. No Elector has ever been prosecuted for failing to vote as pledged. 

There is no link in the original to that Supreme Court decision, so we'll have to take this as read.  I know Lawrence Lessig seems to think that point is still justiciable, but I can't comment on how or why.  Still, just as we now elect Senators directly, we also (albeit somewhat indirectly, if the electors aren't on the ballot), elect our electors.

It's a bit of a Rube Goldberg device, since it doesn't really fulfill Hamilton's vision of the electoral college at all.  It also doesn't raise the hopes of anyone expecting 37 electors to change the face of the outcome called by the Associated Press.*

What it does is call into question the validity of the electoral college.  Yes, the college means politicians have to pay attention to states with less population than New York and California; but Texas is the second most populous state in the union and, despite Hillary Clinton coming within striking distance of Trump without really campaigning here. the DNC is still convinced there's no value in investing in races (as in Louisiana recently) where they don't see a clear and easy path to victory.  The GOP would similarly write off California, and seek heavier voter turnout elsewhere.  You would think both parties would have learned how important voter turnout is, but probably not.

Any outcome is going to be the tyranny of the majority, or of the minority.  Trump's approval rating is currently 48%; his disapproval rating is also 48%.  Which of those groups is the tyrant?  Which group of voters gets to determine the outcome?  The populace?  Or should be it by acreage (or county?  And yes, that measure is falsely reported for this race, but still:  why would it matter?).

Which leads me to a modest proposal.  Doing away with the electoral college is an uphill fight.  Nobody cares about it between quadrennial elections, and few states are going to be inclined to eliminate it, especially the smaller ones (in population, not acreage).  Probably the best solution is to get more states to go the way of Maine and Nebraska, and award electoral votes proportionately, rather than winner-take-all.

If demographics truly is destiny, or if the Democrats can simply be persuaded that Howard Dean was right (yay Vermont!), this might be possible in states where the GOP starts losing its authority.  Redistricting, after all, doesn't effect Presidential votes.  Proceed state by state, and pretty soon almost every state in the Union will want to be on that bandwagon.  And it wouldn't require any change in the Constitution, at all.

Of course, I'd rather go to direct election of the President, as we did with Senators.  But whatever works to get closer to that goal....


*No, seriously, that's who called it.  There is no government agency that determines the outcome of the election prior to the vote of the electoral college.  In fact, that is the government agency that officially determines the outcome of the election.  In that small gap lies the hope of a change from what the AP has reported.


Thursday, December 15, 2016

"No one knows how it started"


I wake up this morning, and I make the mistake of reading this:

It’s true, as Matt Yglesias said, that even if the individual voters in Kliff’s piece had voted for Hillary Clinton, the Democrat still would not have been competitive in Kentucky. But well before Trump appeared on the scene, Kentucky voters had spent the entire Obama administration overwhelmingly voting to send the ACA’s sworn enemies to Congress to kill it, even as they themselves were benefiting from the law. It apparently never occurred to them that they might be seeding the ground for repeal. As long as they stuck it to the big-government coastal elites of the Democratic Party, not much else mattered.

It is hard to recall a more obvious case of voters prizing tribal identity over rational, transactional policy priorities. It has left some on the left angry and frustrated and others furious at that anger and frustration. What it has not done is present any coherent strategy to counter voting behavior that seems irrational. With the level of partisan polarization this country is experiencing, to accompany a real weakening of democratic institutions in the Age of Trump, it is hard to imagine any. That’s the ultimate frustration, and we will be living with it for the foreseeable future.

Which prompted the usual intelligent comments, like this, by someone posting as "Brooklyn Native":

And the bumpkins in flyover country wonder why us coastal folks don't respect them.

I dunno; maybe the new Phil Ochs needs to write a song about people in Kentucky:

In the heat of the summer,
When the pavements were burning.
The soul of a city was ravaged in the night,
After the city sun was sinkin'.

Now no one knows how it started;
Why the windows were shattered,
But deep in the dark, someone set the spark,
And then it no longer mattered.

Down the streets they were rumbling.
All the tempers were raging.
Oh, where, oh, where are the white silver tongues,
Who forgot to listen to the warnings?

On and on came the angry.
No longer following reason.
And all the stores were the target now.
Where just the other day they were buyin'.

Drunk with the memory of the ghetto.
Drunk with the lure of the looting.
And the memory of the uniforms shoving with their sticks,
Asking, "are you looking for trouble? "

"No, no, no," moaned the mayor.
"It's not the way of the order.
Oh stay in your homes, please leave us alone
We'll be glad to talk in the morning."

"For shame, for shame," wrote the papers.
"Why the hurry to your hunger?
Now the rubble's resting on your broken streets.
So see what your rage has unraveled."

Baricades sadly were risin',
Bricks were heavily flyin',
And the loudspeaker drowned like a whisperin' sound,
When compared to the angered emotions.

And when the fury was over,
And the shame was replacing the anger.
So wrong, so wrong, but we've been down too long,
And we had to make somebody listen.


Which brings me back to my thesis that white non-Trump voters now get to find out how blacks and, yes, marginalized whites, have felt for several generations now (never forget the power of racism in the South was held by a minority of wealthy whites who told the poor whites their real enemy was the poor blacks.  When you can't punch up, you punch laterally or down.  I'm almost bemused by the people finding out the world is not their oyster, either.  Or I would be, if not for the ugliness this revelation is revealing.).

Happy Holidays!


It really is as old as the country itself:

 . . . It is a notorious fact that the Monarchs of Europe and the Pope of Rome are at this very moment plotting our destruction and threatening the extinction of our political, civil, and religious institutions. We have the best reasons for believing that corruption has found its way into our Executive Chamber, and that our Executive head is tainted with the infectious venom of Catholicism. . . . The Pope has recently sent his ambassador of state to this country on a secret commission, the effect of which is an extraordinary boldness of the Catholic church throughout the United States. . . . These minions of the Pope are boldly insulting our Senators; reprimanding our Statesmen; propagating the adulterous union of Church and State; abusing with foul calumny all governments but Catholic, and spewing out the bitterest execrations on all Protestantism. The Catholics in the United States receive from abroad more than $200,000 annually for the propagation of their creed. Add to this the vast revenues collected here. . . .
No, not anti-Catholicism; the fear of a shadowy conspiracy that is actually in control.  The quote above is from a Texas newspaper in 1855; it's quoted in Richard Hofstadter's famous article "The Paranoid Style in American Politics."   To put that quote in some perspective:  we are only slightly closer in time to Hofstadter's article than that 1855 article was to 1776; we are much further in time from that article than 1855 is from 1776.  And yet, the more things change.....*

I suppose I should say, at this point:  is it any coincidence that Alex Jones lives in Texas?

I find this kind of conspiratorial ranting even today (and I mean the day I write) in comments at Salon, where some still insist the DNC conspired against Bernie Sanders to give Hillary Clinton the nomination ("the e-mails!  Look at the e-mails!").  The conspiracy theory will always be with us.

What I didn't realize, was how connected to the "War on Christmas" this was:

“The UN fanatics launched their assault on Christmas in 1958, but too late to get very far before the holy day was at hand,” the pamphlet explained. “They are already busy, however, at this very moment, on efforts to poison the 1959 Christmas season with their high-pressure propaganda. What they now want to put over on the American people is simply this: Department stores throughout the country are to utilize UN symbols and emblems as Christmas decorations.”

If John Bolton returns to public life, we may actually hear the UN denounced in those terms again.  But that's the John Birch Society, in 1957.  I can still trace "Happy Holidays" back to Bing Crosby and Irving Berlin (a Jew!  Patience, that will be a point of the discussion, too) in the '40's, but in the disruptive (!) fifth decade of the 20th century, the phrase was already too much to bear in December.

Except drop back another 30 years:

 “The whole record of the Jewish opposition to Christmas, Easter and other Christian festivals, and their opposition to certain patriotic songs, shows the venom and directness of [their] attack,” [Henry] Ford wrote. He listed local outrages: “Christmas celebrations or carols in Philadelphia, Cincinnati, St. Paul and New York met with strong Jewish opposition … Local Council of Jewish Women of Baltimore petitions school board to prohibit Christmas exercises … The Council of the University Settlement, at the request of the New York Kehillah [Jewish leadership], adopts this resolution: ‘That in the holiday celebrations held annually by the Kindergarten Association at the University Settlement every feature of any sectarian character, including Christmas trees, Christmas programs and Christmas songs, shall be eliminated.'”*
It makes me recall my Church History professor in seminary, who delighted to tell the tale of his days at Notre Dame University, when as an "elder" student he would tour prospective families around the campus.  Whenever someone asked who the statute represented atop the main building, he'd always reply it was a nice Jewish girl.  The one who couldn't find a place in the inn, and was chased into Egypt by the powers of this world.  I also remember kindergarten, and Christmas celebrations in kindergarten; and in every year of my childhood in school, even after prayer was banned in school.  That, of course, is not the point.  It's the paranoid style, as Hofstadter defined it, that is the point.

And why am I telling you this?

"So when I started 18 months ago, I told my first crowd in Wisconsin that we are going to come back here someday and we are going to say merry Christmas again," he said to cheers. "Merry Christmas. So, merry Christmas everyone. Happy New Year, but merry Christmas. And I am here today for one main reason: to say thank you to the people of Wisconsin."
As Slate says, Trump has weaponized "Merry Christmas."

Trump is not new; not in anything he does.  He's frightening, but he's as American as violence and cherry pie.  Which is probably even more frightening.

*And have I mentioned my theory that conspiracy theories are attractive because they make the adherents feel special enough to actually be the subject of such complicated machinations?  It explains the tenor of the Texas article (how important the nascent US is that the Pope and the "Monarchs of Europe" would conspire against it), of the Bernie dead-enders (only the combined evil of the Democratic establishment could blunt our savior's victory!), and Trump (well, that goes without saying, doesn't it?).

**I tried to find a direct link to that, but one of the first links was the American Nazi Party, so I declined to go beyond the Google page.

Wednesday, December 14, 2016

There is no rose of such vertu....



I've mentioned somewhere that I sang this with a boy's choir in my feckless youth.  It is still a favorite, after all these years.

Message in a bottle


So I'm watching this show on Netflix about time-travel and trying to change the future (or save it), and trying to send messages to yourself in the past from the future:  all those tangles and paradoxes we think we'd get into if we actually could move freely in time (which Kurt Godel, a far smarter man than I, concluded with sheer logic doesn't exist; time, I mean.  Logic is wonderful, especially when it seems to be so illogical.) and it got me thinking about leaving messages for my future self to unravel.

We are a continuous self, yes?  You shed skin cells, your entire body is "new" compared to the one you were born with, but that's mere persiflage:  you are you.  In fiction (as happens in this TV series I'm watching) you lose your memories, you don't know who "you" are.  Since Locke we've thought that we are who we are because we remember who we are; or were.  Which brings me to the Xmas lights.

I put up no small amount of these things on the house.  Oh, not the Chevy Chase power drain restore the daylight displays.  I have a lot of windows on a house on a corner (so lots of street exposure), and I put lighted wreaths in each one (the details of how I get them to light up is another matter.  Suffice to say I don't want the Fire Dept. inspecting me in December).  I put a large wreath (lighted also) and lights on the storage shed in the back yard (it looks like a miniature barn).  I put lights on the roof of the house, outlining the eaves.  It's no small task putting up these lights (well, at my age), and it involves lots of extension cords, each used for one connection and not another.

And here's where the messages come in.  Every year I look for the boxes of lights, pull them from storage where they've been for 11 months, and dig through them trying to figure out how to do this, again.  Oh, I have some idea of the basics; but the details change annually.  Every year I put the extension cords away (I must have a dozen of them) and the strings of lights (again, a lot; the house has a long side on the street, and an equally long side facing another house, and a garage that gets lights, and the "barn" and the bottle tree in the backyard).  So on and so on and so on....

And every year I pack away the lights with intent, doing it just so in order to leave a message to myself in 11 months on how to do this without reinventing the distribution of cords and lights; and every year, it's a mystery what I was thinking 11 months ago.

I pack the boxes just so, using a particular box for particular items; and I organize the items for convenience, putting related cords together with related lights, or even with related cords.   I even put the boxes away in a certain order.  At least that's what I mean to do; effectively what I actually do is throw everything in a box and pull it out in 11 months and reinvent the wheel; and wonder what I was thinking 11 months ago, to stack the boxes the way I did.

My boxes are time travelers.  Static in time, they travel forward another year, bearing the message of my intentions to the future.  In the future, I open the boxes; but I can't read the message.  Every year I know I packed this box that way for a reason; but the reason is lost to me.

Who packed these boxes?  And what was his relationship to me?  Which me is me?  And what is my relationship to the me of 11 months ago?  Sometimes, when I look at wedding pictures or high school-era snapshots, I see a goofy idiot with no clue, too naive to realize how much he doesn't know, and doesn't want to know.  I remember that guy; he's still with me.  But every time I open those boxes (and don't get me started on the boxes of Christmas decorations in the attic), I wonder:  who was the idiot who did this?  And what was he thinking?

Time travel is bad enough without making it worse.

 
Just to make up for the one I started with....

The awful power of French Aphorisms


This comes from Rick, to whom should go full credit (I haven't read Chernow's Hamilton, and don't intend to; I might like the play, but I still can't quite warm up to musicals that aren't by Sondheim.  I consider this a weakness, not a bragging point.)  It's the quote from Chernow I'm most interested in, because it proves the French right:  the more things change....

In its final report in late May, the Republican-dominated committee could not deliver the comeuppance it had craved.  Instead, it confessed that all the charges lodged against Hamilton were completely baseless, as the treasury secretary had insisted all along.  And what of the endless Jeffersonian insinuations that Hamilton had used public office to extract private credits?  The report concluded that it appears 'that the Secretary of the Treasury never has, either directly or indirectly, for himself or any other person, procured any discount or credit, from either of the said banks...upon the basis of any public monies which, at any time, have been deposited therein under his direction.'  The vindication was so resounding that Hamilton withdrew his long-standing resignation, and his cabinet position grew more impregnable then ever..  Nevertheless, it frustrated him that after this exhaustive investigation his opponents still rehashed the stale charges of misconduct.  He had learned a lesson about propaganda in politics and mused wearily that 'no character, however upright, is a match for constantly reiterated attacks, however false.'  If a charge was made often enough, people assumed in the end 'that a person so often accused cannot be entirely innocent.'
Not just the old chestnut about truth getting its boots on while a lie is half-way 'round the world, but the character of the accusations.  Interestingly, a century or so later, the accusations are an historical footnote.  I suppose there is some comfort in that.  Still, I wonder how many people in Hamilton's day continued to think that, with so much smoke, there must have been some sort of fire?

It also makes one wish the Electoral College would actually, for once in history, work the way Hamilton said it was supposed to.  But the more things change....


Tuesday, December 13, 2016

Let's go to the tape!



Yes, you can see this anywhere.  But I liked it so much....

And I like Olbermann because his anger is so cathartic:

The Kindness of Strangers


Neal Gabler quotes Gore Vidal from 1961 to point out the conservatives we have today were already visible 55 years ago.  He says the problem with the GOP now is, they have no kindness in them, and he wonders where it went.  What he ignores is how much changed, and how fast, in those 55 years. He acts as if the kindness was leached away, went where the socks go in the dryer, was sucked off to some mysterious alternate universal down some mystical black hole.

Where was the kindness in Jim Crow laws?  Where was the kindness in separate but equal?  Where was the kindness in treating women like sex objects and "dolls" and subservient to men (the way they are treated in "Mad Men")?  The kindness that said we must make war because the government said so (which is a "Greatest Generation" phenomena.  There was strong opposition to aiding Europe before Pearl Harbor precisely because it would mean war.  Now we interpret war as our American birthright.).  Where was the kindness to drafting 18 year olds who couldn't vote on the decision to go to war?  The kindness toward the LGBTQ?  The kindness toward anyone who wasn't a white middle to upper class male who knew business was far more important than art, and that real men didn't bake, sew, or dance?

And now the cry is:  where is the kindness toward the standard white male?

It's not even a new cry.  It was the cry of the '70's, and of the '80's, when real men didn't eat quiche.  Yes, the line was a joke, but how often jokes get taken as statements of truth.  The gentle hippie male (still a male chauvinist down to his bare feet) and the mild-mannered Alan Alda, our icon of masculinity in the '70's (alongside the mustachioed louts who filled the TV screen as "action heroes"), quickly gave way to "real men," and John Wayne enjoyed a resurgence and a popularity he'd all but lost in the '60's.  We've seen this struggle over and over again just in my lifetime, as men went from Clark Gable to Jimmy Stewart to Steve McQueen to Alan Alda to Bruce Willis, from Don Draper to Phil Donahue to...Donald Trump?

What begins as tragedy ends as farce, and nothing really different has happened in 55 years, except the backlash.  Alvin Toffler called it "Future shock," but the future is here and now and he was right:  it was the result of too much change too fast.  But standing in the middle of it, we don't see the fast; we just see the change.

And whatever the change is, there is always somebody who doesn't want it.  Somebody doesn't want to change the Thanksgiving menu or change where (or whether) the family meets on holidays, and somebody else wants to keep marriages unmixed by race and somebody else wants to keep it Adam and Eve, not let it be Adam and Steve.  And somebody really, REALLY, REALLY doesn't want to see a black man in the White House.  Enough somebodies to shift a razor thin electoral college victory.

In my lifetime, the one constant has been the aggrieved standard white male.  That, and a general lack of kindness.  As much kindness as we ever showed as a nation, was a result of the affluence of the '60's.  We could afford to be generous then.  We were living better than our parents (or grandparents, as the case may be) had ever dreamed of living.  Everyone could go to college (thanks to the GI Bill)!  Everyone could own a home (thanks to the GI Bill)!  Everyone could find a job (well, every white male, anyway, and who else mattered?)!  We could afford a little largesse!

Then, in the '70's it started to sputter.  Inflation became the scourge of the land, and Paul Volcker taught the Fed its true purpose:  whip inflation now; now and forever.  Then Reagan told us our problem was welfare queens and "young bucks" who took no responsibility for their actions. He didn't have to tell us such people were not white.  12 years of Reagan/Bush, and the best we could do afterwards was the triangulation of Bill Clinton who, if he hadn't done that, would never have been President at all.

And here we are.  Tennessee William's symbol of the South, Blanche DuBois (whiter than white she is; why are there no blacks in his New Orleans?), always trusted to the kindness of strangers.  He meant it as the South's original sin and apologia; all America understood it as the foolishness of the female, and American white males would never be so foolish.  Strangers could not be shown kindness; oh, individuals could, but as a group?

The struggle between competing visions of society was not settled in the 18th century, and wasn't set in stone by the "Founding Fathers" (who never thought of themselves that way, and certainly weren't posing for their monuments in their lifetimes).  The fight for social justice, racial equality, fair if not actually equal treatment under law, due process for all persons, and a share of compassion for everyone, is never won.  It is not a sporting event with a season and a final winner until the next set of competitions.  We haven't become worse than we were; we have become what we are.

We always do.  That isn't the problem.  The problem is letting it rest there.  The problem is looking for someone else to blame, some reason to say it's not your fault, that you had nothing to do with it, that "they" are the reason "we" can't have nice things.  We are the reason.  We are always the reason.  And we always have to struggle, not just with each other, but with ourselves.

Neal Gabler says the GOP has no kindness in them, and he's not wrong.  The desire to end Medicare and Social Security is the desire, not just of Ayn Rand disciples, but of people who care only for money, only for themselves.  The richest donors of the GOP, apparently.   How else to explain the desire to privatize Medicare ASAP, the proposal in this Congress (which must be renewed in the next) to end Social Security?  Is the GOP crazy?  Or dancing with those what brung 'em?

The question is:  who are we dancing with?  Who brung us?

Monday, December 12, 2016

Follow the leader

And he won by landslide!  Just ask him, he'll tell you!

Picking up on what I've been saying today, I want to repeat this comment I left at Thought Criminal earlier:

I realized this morning that there is no federal agency which announces the collated results of the election in November. The FEC doesn't do it (from the name you would think they would). No government agency does it.

The Associated Press does it.

In the days following the election, it was the Associated Press that announced how many electoral college votes Trump and Clinton each had. Of course, they don't have any until the electoral college votes, but that vote is superfluous to the reports of the AP. It's a foregone conclusion. The meeting of the college and the casting of their votes is quaint tradition from times gone by. It's vestigial.

Why is the AP right? I'm not introducing a conspiracy theory, I'm just asking: why does our democracy work this way? We don't look to the AP to decide who won Senate races, House races, races in local elections. Sure, they predict winners, down to a certain level; but that announcement doesn't mean someone won. Except in the case of the POTUS.

AP has announced the results; the only thing left is the inauguration. When did the AP become the official arbiter of who won the White House? Because if the EC doesn't vote the way AP says they should, it will be a "Constitutional Crisis" because: AP has already called the race.

How dare the EC challenge the AP?

Adding: how dare the electors seek to do their constitutional duty?

Open Letter to Director of National Intelligence James Clapper:

We are Electors who were selected by the voters of our states to represent them in the Electoral College on December 19, 2016. We intend to discharge our duties as Electors by ensuring that we select a candidate for president who, as our Founding Fathers envisioned, would be “endowed with the requisite qualifications.” As Electors, we also believe that deliberation is at the heart of democracy itself, not an empty or formalistic task. We do not understand our sole function to be to convene in mid-December, several weeks after Election Day, and summarily cast our votes. To the contrary, the Constitution envisions the Electoral College as a deliberative body that plays a critical role in our system of government — ensuring that the American people elect a president who is constitutionally qualified and fit to serve. Accordingly, to fulfill our role as Electors, we seek an informed and unrestrained opportunity to fulfill our constitutional role leading up to December 19th — that is, the ability to investigate, discuss, and deliberate with our colleagues about whom to vote for in the Electoral College.

We further emphasize Alexander Hamilton’s assertion in Federalist Paper #68 that a core purpose of the Electoral College was to prevent a “desire in foreign powers to gain an improper ascendant in our councils.” The United States intelligence community has now concluded with “high confidence” that a foreign power, namely Russia, acted covertly to interfere in the presidential campaign with the intent of promoting Donald Trump’s candidacy. During the campaign Russia actively attempted to influence the election outcome through cyber attacks on our political institutions and a comprehensive propaganda campaign coordinated through Wikileaks and other outlets.
Allegations that Donald Trump was receiving assistance from a hostile foreign power to win the election began months before Election Day. When presented with information that the Russian government was interfering in the election through the course of the campaign, both in private briefings and public assessment, Donald Trump rejected it, refused to condemn it, and continued to accept their help. Donald Trump even made a direct plea to the Russian government to interfere further in the election in a press conference on July 27, saying, “Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing.”

According to reports in the Washington Post, New York Times, and other outlets, the United States intelligence community has now concluded definitively that the Russian interference was performed to help Donald Trump get elected, yet even today Mr. Trump is refusing to accept that finding. In response to the reports, the Trump transition office instead released a statement which called into question the validity of United States intelligence findings, and declared the election over despite the Electoral College not yet casting its votes. Trump’s willingness to disregard conclusions made by the intelligence community and his continuing defense of Russia and Russian President Vladimir Putin demand close scrutiny and deliberation from the Electoral College.

Separate from Mr. Trump’s own denials of Russian involvement in the election, the confirmed communication between Trump’s aides and those associated with the Russian election interference activity raise serious concerns that must be addressed before we cast our votes. Trump-confidant Roger Stone confirmed during the campaign that he was engaged in back-channel communications with Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, responsible for releasing much of the Russian-hacked Democratic communications, and indicated that he was aware of the hacked content prior to its release. Trump foreign policy advisor Carter Page reportedly visited Moscow in July of this year, just prior to the release of hacked DNC communications, during which it was believed he met with the Putin aide in charge of Russian intelligence on the U.S. election. Page returned to Moscow this week where he claimed to be meeting with Russian business and thought leaders.

In addition to Donald Trump and his aides’ conduct, revelations about their further involvement with the Russian government over the course of the campaign demand further investigation, as well as full disclosure of findings from any ongoing or closed investigative efforts:

  • Russian government officials revealed that they had maintained contact with the Trump campaign during the election, and stated that they were familiar with most of the individuals associated with Mr. Trump.
  • Media inquiries into whether the FBI was investigating Donald Trump’s July plea for Russian interference in the election resulted in a “Glomar response” neither confirming nor denying the existence of an investigation, rather than the more typical response of denying the request outright.
  • U.S. intelligence officials reportedly probed Trump foreign policy advisor Carter Page in regard to travel to his Moscow during the campaign.
  • The FBI reportedly began an inquiry into Trump associates following reports of a multi-million dollar business relationship with pro-Putin figures in Ukraine and Russia, and reports of an effort to sway American public opinion in favor of Ukraine’s pro-Putin government.
  • Michael Flynn, Trump campaign aide and the announced incoming National Security Advisor, traveled to Russia in December of 2015 for a gala event celebrating RT, a state-controlled propaganda network, at which he was seated next to Russian President Vladimir Putin.

The Electors require to know from the intelligence community whether there are ongoing investigations into ties between Donald Trump, his campaign or associates, and Russian government interference in the election, the scope of those investigations, how far those investigations may have reached, and who was involved in those investigations. We further require a briefing on all investigative findings, as these matters directly impact the core factors in our deliberations of whether

Mr. Trump is fit to serve as President of the United States.

Additionally, the Electors will separately require from Donald Trump conclusive evidence that he and his staff and advisors did not accept Russian interference, or otherwise collaborate during the campaign, and conclusive disavowal and repudiation of such collaboration and interference going forward.
We hope that the information and actions described in this letter will be provided in an expeditious manner, so that we can fulfill our constitutional duty as Electors.

I just decided the whole thing was worth quoting.  This could get interesting.

Catching up:

Newest to oldest:








Clearly everything he says must be true!

What, me worry?

Crazy enough for you?

He doesn't worry; but I do.

I've been out this morning, so I missed this bit of information:

Trump said Sunday that he could do away with the so-called "one-China" policy — an agreement by the United States to effectively side with China in its sovereignty dispute with the self-proclaimed republic of Taiwan… "China expresses serious concern on this subject," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Geng Shuang told reporters. "If the [one China policy] is compromised or interfered with, any sound and steady development in China-U.S. relations and cooperation in various fields is out of the question…"I fully understand the 'one China' policy, but I don't know why we have to be bound by a 'one China' policy unless we make a deal with China having to do with other things, including trade," Trump said.

This explains why I came into the middle of an interview on NPR with a national security expert and professor at some college (so an Authority on the Subject) who said this is what you don't do, because China is a nuclear power, and this is the one issue he can see China going to war over:  Taiwan and its status.

Is this enough for the Electoral College to man up and do something?  They could keep it out of the House entirely, frankly.  It would be better than giving this idiot any chance at sitting behind that desk in that office.

"But they're sure comin' slow..."



It is clear now the Trump Administration will lie the way ordinary people draw breath:  it's a matter of course, they don't even think about it.

These are the same people that said Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. The election ended a long time ago in one of the biggest Electoral College victories in history. It's now time to move on and 'Make America Great Again.'
"The election ended a long time ago":  the Electoral College has yet to meet, but the election is ancient history.  Please to be moving on.  "[O]ne of the biggest Electoral College victories in history."  Except for all the other elections that didn't end in a tie, or with the winning candidate getting fewer popular votes than the losing candidate.  But why niggle over details?   It is now time to move on.  After all, our democracy is so fragile.

Isn't it?

We were persuaded that we were far too delicate these days for the kind of brawling politics in which this country had been born, and for which the Founders had set up the Constitution to maintain something resembling boundaries. We were fed cheap junk food instead of actual information until we developed a serious jones for it. Our belief in our counterfeit national innocence was that with which we washed it all down. We became a fat and lazy excuse for a democratic republic.

Because we must know who won the electoral college vote before midnight on Election Day.  Because we mustn't question the wisdom of polling, the reports of the Associated Press (the entity that apparently determines which candidate won the electoral college vote, weeks before that entity actually meets to vote), and because we don't even blink at claims the election was a long time ago, and the margin of victory was huge; even though we know it wasn't.  Words, what do they matter?  It's feelings that count.  Besides, the election was a long time ago; we have Christmas shopping to do.

And, like Jonathan Chait, I don't have a good feeling about this:

The Obama administration declined to publicize, wary of being seen as intervening on Clinton’s behalf. Instead, it devised a fallback plan. Concerned that Russia might attempt to hack into electronic voting machines, it gathered a bipartisan group of lawmakers to hear the CIA’s report, in the hopes that they would present a united front warning Russia not to disrupt the election. According to the Post, Republican Majority Leader Mitch McConnell “raised doubts about the underlying intelligence and made clear to the administration that he would consider any effort by the White House to challenge the Russians publicly an act of partisan politics.” Other Republicans refused to join the effort for reasons that can only be understood as a desire to protect the Republican ticket from any insinuation, however well-founded, that Russia was helping it.

Even the most cynical observer of McConnell — a cynical man to his bones — would have been shocked at his raw partisanship. Presented with an attack on the sanctity of his own country’s democracy by a hostile foreign power, his overriding concern was party over country. Obama’s fear of seeming partisan held him back from making a unilateral statement without partisan cover. No such fear restrained McConnell. This imbalance in will to power extended to the security agencies. The CIA could have leaked its conclusion before November, but held off. The FBI should have held off on leaking its October surprise, but plunged ahead.

Cynical?  Then how do we describe the President-Elect?

President-elect Donald Trump, in an exclusive interview with “Fox News Sunday,” decried as “ridiculous” the CIA’s reported assessment that Russia intervened in the election to boost his candidacy – describing the claim as another “excuse” pushed by Democrats to explain his upset victory.

“It's just another excuse. I don't believe it,” Trump said. “… Every week it's another excuse.  We had a massive landslide victory, as you know, in the Electoral College."

And you wonder why Obama didn't push that intelligence information in September?

By the way; in 1972 Richard Nixon won 49 states and 520 electoral votes.  I'm old enough to remember that.  That was a landslide victory.    LBJ won 486 electoral votes, to Goldwater's 52.  That was a landslide victory.   I'm old enough to remember that, too.  Trump lies as casually as other people say "Hello."

Country doesn't matter anymore.  We learned that in November.  All that matters is power, is victory, is winning.  Once you win you control reality, you get to call a squeaker victory the greatest rout in history; you get to call a crude lout "Mr. President."  You get to berate people who don't look like you because this is your country now and if someone doesn't like that fact they can leave!

I'm old enough to remember "America:  Love it or leave it!"  This time around, I think they mean it.

"Good times are comin'....."

I had this, below, written when I found that tweet above.  To put things in perspective, Edgar Welch entered Cosmic Ping Pong on December 4th, and found nothing.  Michael Flynn tweeted about "Pizzagate" (not for the first time!) the next day.  According to Gen. McCaffrey, Flynn just doesn't understand social media.

 On MSNBC Friday, December 9:

MELVIN: Retired four star general is raising red flags over president-elect Donald Trump's pick for national security advisor. Specifically concerns about Mike Flynn's Twitter feed, a site that includes posts propagating conspiracy theories and so-called fake news as well. I'm joined now by the retired military man with some harsh feedback, retired general McCaffrey, military analyst, of course. What's your chief gripe here?

MCCAFFREY: Let me say, by the way, I was somewhat reassured last night to get a long e-mail from General Flynn. What we may have here is a case of real inexperience on dealing with social media as these people move from this savage campaign mode into governance. Twitter feed may be better for teenage intrigue than policy formulation. When they're retweeting these on nonsense fantasy stories, I'm not sure they understood they seem to be endorsing them.

Well, it ain't just Twitter:

"I know from my friends in the Border Patrol in CBP that there are countries -- radical Islamist countries, state-sponsored -- that are cutting deals with Mexican drug cartels for some of what they call the 'lanes of entry' into our country… "And I have personally seen the photos of the signage along those paths that are in Arabic. They're like way points along that path as you come in. Primarily, in this case the one that I saw was in Texas and it's literally, it's like signs, that say, in Arabic, 'this way, move to this point.' It's unbelievable."

That's Flynn on a radio interview (the Border Patrol, by the way, knows nothing about such signs).  Then there's his record with the Defense Intelligence Agency:

He has called President Obama a “liar,” declared the U.S. justice system “corrupt” and insisted that he was pushed out of his assignment as director of the Defense Intelligence Agency because of his views on radical Islam. The claim has left former superiors seething, including Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr., according to current and former officials who said Flynn was removed because of management problems.

Like Trump, Flynn has advocated forging closer ties with Russia. In interviews with The Washington Post, Flynn acknowledged being paid to give a speech and attend a lavish anniversary party for the Kremlin-controlled RT television network in Moscow last year, where he was seated next to Russian President Vladi­mir Putin.

“People went crazy,” said retired Brig. Gen. Peter B. Zwack, a former U.S. military attache in Moscow. “They thought it was so out of bounds, so unusual.” Zwack emphasized that he considers Flynn a “patriot” who “would never sell out his country.”

Flynn, who was no longer in government but received a DIA briefing on Russia before the trip, said the invitation and payment came through his speaker’s bureau. He said he used the visit to press for collaboration on Syria, Iran and the Middle East, and dismissed the ensuing controversy as “boring.” Asked why he would want to be so closely associated with a Kremlin propaganda platform, Flynn said he sees no distinction between RT and other news outlets.

“What’s CNN? What’s MSNBC? Come on!” said Flynn, who also has appeared occasionally as an unpaid on-air analyst for RT and other foreign broadcasters.

Forget ideology, why do we want to put his man in charge of national security?  And even if he really was fired because of his views on radical Islam, I'd think that was a good thing, too.  His views on Islam and Arabs are clearly nuts.

The explanation of "Pizzagate" is here, including an explanation of Flynn's reference to Podesta's e-mails.  Flynn has not retracted that tweet, or apparently changed his opinion in any way.  The only difference between Michael Flynn and Edgar Welch is that Mr. Welch realizes he was wrong.

This is not something that can be corrected by an apologetic e-mail.  This man is dangerously delusional.

Sunday, December 11, 2016

Third Sunday of Advent 2016: "A reed shaken by the wind."


Isaiah 35:1-10
35:1 The wilderness and the dry land shall be glad, the desert shall rejoice and blossom; like the crocus

35:2 it shall blossom abundantly, and rejoice with joy and singing. The glory of Lebanon shall be given to it, the majesty of Carmel and Sharon. They shall see the glory of the LORD, the majesty of our God.

35:3 Strengthen the weak hands, and make firm the feeble knees.

35:4 Say to those who are of a fearful heart, "Be strong, do not fear! Here is your God. He will come with vengeance, with terrible recompense. He will come and save you."

35:5 Then the eyes of the blind shall be opened, and the ears of the deaf unstopped;

35:6 then the lame shall leap like a deer, and the tongue of the speechless sing for joy. For waters shall break forth in the wilderness, and streams in the desert;

35:7 the burning sand shall become a pool, and the thirsty ground springs of water; the haunt of jackals shall become a swamp, the grass shall become reeds and rushes.

35:8 A highway shall be there, and it shall be called the Holy Way; the unclean shall not travel on it, but it shall be for God's people; no traveler, not even fools, shall go astray.

35:9 No lion shall be there, nor shall any ravenous beast come up on it; they shall not be found there, but the redeemed shall walk there.

35:10 And the ransomed of the LORD shall return, and come to Zion with singing; everlasting joy shall be upon their heads; they shall obtain joy and gladness, and sorrow and sighing shall flee away.

Psalm 146:5-10
146:5 Happy are those whose help is the God of Jacob, whose hope is in the LORD their God,

146:6 who made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them; who keeps faith forever;

146:7 who executes justice for the oppressed; who gives food to the hungry. The LORD sets the prisoners free;

146:8 the LORD opens the eyes of the blind. The LORD lifts up those who are bowed down; the LORD loves the righteous.

146:9 The LORD watches over the strangers; he upholds the orphan and the widow, but the way of the wicked he brings to ruin.

146:10 The LORD will reign forever, your God, O Zion, for all generations. Praise the LORD!

Luke 1:46b-55
1:46b "My soul magnifies the Lord,

1:47 and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,

1:48 for he has looked with favor on the lowliness of his servant. Surely, from now on all generations will call me blessed;

1:49 for the Mighty One has done great things for me, and holy is his name.

1:50 His mercy is for those who fear him from generation to generation.

1:51 He has shown strength with his arm; he has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts.

1:52 He has brought down the powerful from their thrones, and lifted up the lowly;

1:53 he has filled the hungry with good things, and sent the rich away empty.

1:54 He has helped his servant Israel, in remembrance of his mercy,

1:55 according to the promise he made to our ancestors, to Abraham and to his descendants forever."

James 5:7-10
5:7 Be patient, therefore, beloved, until the coming of the Lord. The farmer waits for the precious crop from the earth, being patient with it until it receives the early and the late rains.

5:8 You also must be patient. Strengthen your hearts, for the coming of the Lord is near.

5:9 Beloved, do not grumble against one another, so that you may not be judged. See, the Judge is standing at the doors!

5:10 As an example of suffering and patience, beloved, take the prophets who spoke in the name of the Lord.

Matthew 11:2-11
11:2 When John heard in prison what the Messiah was doing, he sent word by his disciples

11:3 and said to him, "Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?"

11:4 Jesus answered them, "Go and tell John what you hear and see:

11:5 the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news brought to them.

11:6 And blessed is anyone who takes no offense at me."

11:7 As they went away, Jesus began to speak to the crowds about John: "What did you go out into the wilderness to look at? A reed shaken by the wind?

11:8 What then did you go out to see? Someone dressed in soft robes? Look, those who wear soft robes are in royal palaces.

11:9 What then did you go out to see? A prophet? Yes, I tell you, and more than a prophet.

11:10 This is the one about whom it is written, 'See, I am sending my messenger ahead of you, who will prepare your way before you.'

11:11 Truly I tell you, among those born of women no one has arisen greater than John the Baptist; yet the least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he.

The least in the kingdom of heaven are greater than John the Baptizer because the first shall be last and the last first in that kingdom.  Because God has brought down the powerful from their thrones and lifted up the lowly.  Because the Lord watches over the widow and the orphan, and brings the way of the wicked to ruin.

And because no one goes out into the desert to see a reed shaken by the wind.

The Magnificat of Mary is not a call to revolution, or a plea for God's justice.  It is a cry of joy, the response to Elizabeth's greeting to her cousin.  Don't take it as a part of the New Testament, or the basis for any Christian doctrine; take it out of its place in history and put it back where it started.  Luke didn't write his gospel to be one of four, or for us to read.  He gave Mary this song for reasons all his own.

Luke gives us the Jesus of social justice.  It's Luke's Jesus who goes to the Temple to read from the scriptures and chooses Isaiah, and tells the men there that the day Isaiah told about has come.  By the time you read that, you've read four songs for Jesus' nativity.  Mary's is the longest, and the boldest; and it's meant to be prologue to the story that follows.

If the Baptizer didn't wear soft robes and live in a royal palace, neither did Mary.

"My soul magnifies the Lord," she says.   A less poetic, and less obscure, translation would be:  "My soul extols the Lord."  That puts the emphasis in the right place, but the whole song is about the day of the Lord the prophets warned about:  a day of darkness, not light.  Well, not light to some; the cracks that let the light in are blessing to somebody, if only because the light gets in:

He has shown strength with his arm; he has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts.

1:52 He has brought down the powerful from their thrones, and lifted up the lowly;

1:53 he has filled the hungry with good things, and sent the rich away empty.

It starts with the internal, the "thoughts of their hearts." It moves the external; the powerful are brought down from their thrones, the lowly lifted up; the hungry fed, the rich sent away with nothing.  Jesus will say the same thing in his most famous sermon:  "Congratulations to you hungry!  You will be fed!  Damn you rich!  You have received your reward!"

Nowhere in the gospels does anyone go into the desert to see a reed shaken by the wind.  And "The Advent mystery is the beginning of the end of all in us that is not yet Christ."  That beginning is part of Mary's cry of joy.  She is not declaring what will happen, or what should happen, or what has to happen.  Her song declares what has happened, just as Jesus said:  "Go and tell John what you see and hear."  And it's not a reed blowing in the wind.

Happy are those whose help is the God of Jacob, whose hope is in the LORD their God,

who made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that is in them; who keeps faith forever;

who executes justice for the oppressed; who gives food to the hungry. The LORD sets the prisoners free;

the LORD opens the eyes of the blind. The LORD lifts up those who are bowed down; the LORD loves the righteous.

 The LORD watches over the strangers; he upholds the orphan and the widow, but the way of the wicked he brings to ruin.

It's not that God will execute justice for the oppressed, or will give good to the hungry, or will set the prisoners free, open the eyes of the blind, lift up those who are bowed down:  those are not promises, they are statements.  God doesn't wait; God does.  Congratulations to you hungry! God has brought down the powerful from their thrones, and lifted up the lowly; God has filled the hungry with good things, and sent the rich away empty.  God has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts.

God has done it; God will do it; God is doing it.  The maker of heaven and earth is not a reed blowing in the wind.  And the way has to be prepared:  over and over again, we have to renew this sense of wonder and of mystery and of awe.

God has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts.  It may not seem that way, but it is true.  And if we let the thoughts of our hearts scatter us, then it isn't that God is not present, or attentive; it is that we have joined "the proud."  It could be we whose eyes are not opened, because we won't let them be; we who are still prisoners because we will not walk out of our cell; we who are hungry because we will not eat; we who are sent away empty, because we want to stay rich.  Mary rejoices in what God has done for her, and yet God has done nothing material, and in fact John is in jail.  The powers of the world have imprisoned him, only death sets him free.

At least that's the way the powers of the world would see it.  John is not free, Mary is still poor, and Jesus is just taking over what John had started.   That's the way the world sees it.  But the Lord opens the eyes of the blind, lifts up the bowed down, loves the righteous.  The Lord watches over the strangers and upholds the widow and the orphan; the powerless, the ones at the margin.

And that is the real power of this world.  That is far more than soft robes and palaces; and it is much more than a reed bending in the wind. It is the reversal of all the world was certain was true.  It is the blossoming of the desert.  It is the opening of the blind eye and deaf ear.  It is the dance of the crippled who now walk.  It is water in the dry land, and sorrow and sighing fleeing away.

Happy are those whose hope is in the Lord their God.




Saturday, December 10, 2016

December 10 (from the archives)


"The Advent mystery is the beginning of the end of all in us that is not yet Christ."

--Thomas Merton


MERTON'S most important experience in his whole Asian trip came at Polonnaruwa. He went to visit the giant Buddhas and took a series of superb photographs of them.

I am able to approach the Buddhas barefoot and undisturbed, my feet in wet grass, wet sand. The silence of the extraordinary faces. The great smi les. Huge and yet subtle. Filled with every possibility, questioning nothing, knowing everything, rejecting nothing, the peace not of emotional refutation. . . that has seen through every question without trying to discredit anyone or anything-without refutation-without establishing some other argument. For the doctrinaire, the mind that needs well-established positions, such peace, such silence, can be frightening. I was knocked over with a rush of relief and thankfulness at the obvious clarity of the figures. . . . Looking at these figures I was suddenly, almost forcibly, jerked clean out of the habitual, half-tied vision of things, and an inner clearness, clarity, as if exploding from the rocks themselves, became evident and obvious. . . . I don't know when in my life I have ever had such a sense of beauty and spiritual validity running together in one aesthetic illumination. Surely, with Mahabalipuram and Polonnaruwa my Asian pilgrimage has come clear and purified itself. I mean, I know and have seen what I was obscurely looking for. I don't know what else remains but I have now seen and have pierced through the surface and have got beyond the shadow and the disguise.

That was on December 4. . . . [On December 10, after addressing the conference in Bangkok,] Merton had lunch and did disappear to his room, commenting to a colleague on the way about how much he was looking forward to having a siesta. In a long letter later written by the delegates at the Conference to Dom Flavian what then occurred was expressed in the following words: "Not long after he retired a shout was heard by others in his cottage, but after a preliminary check they thought'they must have imagined the cry.

"He was found at the end of the meridian (afternoon rest) and when found was lying on the floor. He was on his back with the electric fan lying across his chest. The fan was still switched on, and there was a deep burn and some cuts on his right side and arm. The back of his head was also bleeding slightly."

Perhaps any death brings with it both a sense of surprise and a sense of its inevitability. There are always those, and there were many after Merton's death, who feel that it somehow "had to be like that." Merton had, from time to time, both spoken and written comments that suggested that his death might come early. Some of his friends commented on the extraordinary, almost Zen-like way that death had come to him. Fewer people than one might expect noted that he died on the same day as the great Protestant theologian Karl Barth, and it was a measure of the ecumenism in Louisville, which Merton had been instrumental in promoting, that Catholics and Protestants there united in a joint memorial service for both of them.

Many years before Naomi Burton had made the suggestion, humorously, that Merton was accident-prone. "I couldn't help noticing that it's your visitors who get locked out of the church, and your server who forgets things, and your vestments that get caught in the folding chair. . . . I find your incredible adventures with nature and with publishing extremely endearing." Perhaps Merton was accident-prone; perhaps, like many intellectuals, he tended to get lost in his thinking, and absentmindedly forgot about the dangers of touching electrical equipment with wet hands; perhaps the fan was merely faulty. Perhaps, however, he had finished his life six days before at Polonnaruwa and was called to the God he had loved and served so well.

--Monica Furlong

The sermon I gave [at the conference on monasticism the morning after Merton's death] was a moment of talkinga bout Merton's search for God.  When a monk enters a monastery, what is asked of him is "Are you truly seeking God?"  The question isn't "Have you found God?"  The question is "Is he seeking God?  Is his motivation highly involved in that search of who and what God is in relationship to us?"  It's not philosophical--it's existential.  And Merton, to me, was a great searcher.  He was constantly unhappy, as all great searchers are.  He was constantly ill at ease, he was constantly restless, as all searchers are--because that's part of the search.  And in that sense he was the perfect monk.  Contemplation isn't satisfaction--it's search.

--Rembert Weakland

Charm with your stainlessness these winter nights,
Skies, and be perfect!
Fly vivider in the fiery dark, you quiet meteors,
And disappear.
You moon, be slow to go down,
This is your fill!

The four white roads make off in silence
Towards the four parts of the starry universe.
Time falls like manna at the corners of the wintry earth.
We have become more humble than the rocks,
More wakeful than the patient hills.

Charm with your stainlessness these nights in Advent, holy spheres,
While minds, as meek as beasts,
Stay close at home in the sweet hay;
And intellects are quieter than the flocks that feed by starlight.

Oh pour your darkness and your brightness over all our solemn valleys,
Your skies:  and travel like the gentle Virgin,
Towards the planets' stately setting,

O white moon full as quiet as Bethlehem!

--Thomas Merton

Friday, December 09, 2016

"...that has such creatures in it!"



If you aren't worried about Donald Trump, this is why you should be:

About a year ago, 18-year-old college student Lauren Batchelder stood up at a political forum in New Hampshire and told Donald Trump that she didn’t think he was “a friend to women.”

The next morning, Trump fired back on Twitter — calling Batchelder an “arrogant young woman” and accusing her of being a “plant” from a rival campaign. Her phone began ringing with callers leaving threatening messages that were often sexual in nature. Her Facebook and email inboxes filled with similar messages. As her addresses circulated on social media and her photo flashed on the news, she fled home to hide.

“I didn’t really know what anyone was going to do,” said Batchelder, now 19, who has never discussed her experience with a reporter until now. “He was only going to tweet about it and that was it, but I didn’t really know what his supporters were going to do, and that to me was the scariest part.”

This is what happens when Trump targets a private citizen who publicly challenges him.
Chuck Jones, President of United Steelworkers Local 1999, was barely off of CNN before death threats starting coming to him because of Trump's tweets about his statements there.

Mary sings in her Magnificat, a song both sung and read regularly during Advent, that God has scattered the proud in the thoughts of their hearts.  This is as fine an example of that as I've ever seen.  But that doesn't make it any less dangerous, or damaging.  Trump, by the way, sees nothing wrong with this.  He thinks having a Twitter account is: “like owning the New York Times without the losses.”  Well, without any losses to him; and that's all that matters.

With one tweet last week, Trump inflamed a conflict with China. With another tweet on Tuesday, Trump caused Boeing stock to plummet. With a third on Wednesday night, Trump prompted a series of threatening calls to the home of a union leader who had called him a liar.

We have given a child a loaded shotgun, and it's going to be a long time before we figure out how to take it away from him.  And a lot of damage is going to be done before we do.

Adding:  now it turns out that phone call from Taiwan wasn't a spur of the moment decision:

Last week’s telephone call between President-elect Donald Trump and Taiwan’s president was the result of six months of behind-the-scenes work by former Sen. Bob Dole acting on behalf of the Taiwanese government, according to federal filings and published reports.

The call was a breach of diplomatic protocol, and Trump advisers have made conflicting statements about whether it signaled a new policy toward China. Taiwan split from China in 1949, but China still considers the island part of its territory and would consider it unacceptable for the U.S. to recognize Taiwan’s leader as a head of state.

So:  Trump is a dupe of his advisors, because he has no clue what is going on and listens to the last person who spoke to him; or he's a Machivaellian statesman of the highest order.

Only one of these conclusions seems likely; neither is comforting.

Thursday, December 08, 2016

The Art of the Squeal

The contretemps du jour is that Trump didn't save 1100 jobs, he only saved 730-750 jobs (estimates vary).

But if you take into account that Carrier said in March it would leave 400 jobs behind, then Trump really only saved a little over 300 jobs.

At a cost to Indiana taxpayers of $7 million.

What a deal!